98 3. DUMPING › 3.3. Comparison, Regulation (EU) 2021/1930

In forcesince 8 Nov 2021cited 1×

Third, the group claimed that while the Commission in recital (68) of the provisional Regulation referred to “numerous clauses, such as an arbitration clause, showing a lack of solidarity between the companies”, it mentioned only one: the “arbitration clause”. At the same time, in the judgment PT Musim Mas, the General Court did refer to several types of clauses as evidence of a lack of solidarity. The clause on arbitration is allegedly not sufficient for the Commission to conclude that no SEE exists. As explained in recital (68) of the provisional Regulation, the commission contracts between Sveza-Les and the mills contain numerous provisions showing lack of solidarity between the companies and was thus evidence of the existence of two economic entities with divergent interests [Judgment of 14 July 2021, Interpipe Niko Tube LLC v Commission, T-716/19. ECLI:EU:T:2021:457, para. 163.]. Other than the arbitration clause, the liability of the parties to the contract is limited only in case of force majeure whereas in all other situations the parties are responsible for non-performance or improper performance of obligations arising from the contracts in accordance with the generally applicable legislation of the Russian Federation. The contracts further contain provisions governing communications between Sveza-Les and the mills and their obligations in the event of a change of name or address. These non-exhaustive examples along with the arbitration clause mentioned in the provisional regulation constitute evidence that the relationship between the Sveza-Les and the producers as far as export sales are concerned is organised on the basis of normal commercial conditions. Consequently, the claim was rejected.

  • Judgment of the General Court (Sixth Chamber) of 11 September 2024. Sveza Verkhnyaya Sinyachikha NAO and Others v European Commission.Decision

    In the present case, it is apparent from recitals 67, 68 and 71 of the provisional regulation and recitals 95, 97 to 106, 108 and 113 of the contested regulation that the Commission relied, in essence, on four factors in order to reject …

    11 Sep 2024 · 62022TJ0002