To bring an action before the IPT (‘standing requirement’), according to Section 65 of the RIPA 2000, an individual has to believe (i) that the conduct of an intelligence service has taken place in relation to him, any of his property, any communications sent by or to him, or intended for him, or his use of any postal service, telecommunications service or telecommunications system [Section 65(4) of the RIPA 2000.], and (ii) that the conduct has taken place in ‘challengeable circumstances’ [Such circumstances refer to conduct of public authorities taking place with authority (e.g. an warrant, an authorisation/notice for the acquisition of communications, etc.), or if the circumstances are such that (whether or not there is such authority) it would not have been appropriate for the conduct to take place without it, or at least without proper consideration having been given to whether such authority should be sought. Conduct authorised by a Judicial Commissioner are considered as to have taken place in challengeable circumstance (Section 65 (7ZA) of the RIPA 2000) while other conducts that take place with the permission of a person holding judicial office are considered not to have taken place in challengeable circumstance (Section 65(7) and (8) of the RIPA 2000).] or ‘been carried out by or on behalf of the intelligence services [According to the information provided by United Kingdom authorities, the low threshold for making a complaint determines that it is not unusual for the Tribunal’s investigation to determine that the complainant was in fact never subject to investigation by a public authority. The latest Statistical Report of the IPT specifies that in 2016 the Tribunal received 209 complaints, 52 % of those were considered frivolous or vexatious and 25 % received a ‘no determination’ outcome. United Kingdom authorities explained that this either means that no covert activity/powers were used in relation to the complainant, or that covert techniques were used and the Tribunal determined that the activity was lawful. Additionally, 11 % were ruled out of jurisdiction, withdrawn or not valid, 5 % were ruled out of time, 7 % were found in favour of the complainant. Statistical Report of the Investigatory Powers Tribunal 2016, available at the following link: https://www.ipt-uk.com/docs/IPT%20Statisical%20Report%202016.pdf]. As in particular this ‘belief’ standard has been interpreted quite broadly [See case Human Rights Watch v Secretary of State [2016] UKIPTrib15_165-CH. In this case, the IPT, by referring to the ECtHR case-law, held that the appropriate test in respect of the belief that any conduct falling within Subsection 68(5) of RIPA 2000 has been carried out by or on behalf of any of the intelligence services is whether there is any basis for such belief, including the fact that an individual may claim to be a victim of a violation occasioned by the mere existence of secret measures or legislation permitting secret measures, only if he is able to show that due to his personal situation, he is potentially at risk of being subjected to such measures (see Human Rights Watch v Secretary of State, paragraph 41).], bringing a case before the Tribunal is subject to relatively low standing requirements.
151 2. RULES APPLYING TO THE PROCESSING OF PERSONAL DATA BY COMPETENT AUTHORITIES FOR THE CRIMINAL LAW ENFORCEMENT PURPOSES › 2.6. Onward sharing, Decision_act (EU) 2021/1773
In forcesince 28 Jun 2021