4. ASSESSMENT OF THE AID › 4.3. Compatibility of the aid and the legal basis for the assessment › 4.3.3. Restructuring plan and return to long-term viability › 4.3.3.2. Doubts on the return to long-term viability, Decision_act (EU) 2020/1012

In forcesince 24 Feb 2020
(144)

Table 7 shows that CNU would fail to reach long-term viability if selling UO2 at market price under the notified restructuring plan, even under the (optimistic) assumption that the production cost of the new mine (including proper coverage of future environmental liabilities) would be equal to current market price for yellow cake (i.e. RON 350 per kgU of U3O8). In effect, the revenues from sales of UO2 at market price would be lower than CNU’s production costs. Accordingly, its ROE, ROA and ROCE would all be negative at the end of the restructuring period. On that basis, even with supplies from the new mine, the third restructuring plan submitted by Romania does not allow concluding that CNU would be viable on the market when selling at market prices.

Table 7

Actual and projected financial results of CNU (sale of UO2 at market price)

Source: Commission calculations based on data in Third restructuring plan.

In RON million | 2017 | 2018 | 2019 (f) | 2020 (f) | 2021 (f) | 2022 (f) | 2023 (f)

historical revenues | 84,1 | 37,8 | | | | |

non-UO2 related revenues | | | 12,9 | 15,4 | 16,5 | 16,9 | 17,4

UO2 related revenues | | | 93,12 | 93,12 | 93,12 | 93,12 | 93,12

Total Turnover | 84,1 | 37,8 | 106,0 | 108,5 | 109,6 | 110,1 | 110,5

Feldioara costs | 42,98 | 28,38 | 42,53 | 41,73 | 40,61 | 39,27 | 37,84

Central costs | 7,77 | 4,29 | 7,77 | 7,77 | 7,77 | 7,77 | 7,77

Suceava | | | | | | |

mining costs (assuming a production cost equal to market price) | na | na | 84 | 84 | 84 | 84 | 84

Net profit | na | na | -28,4 | -25,1 | -22,8 | -21,1 | -19,2

adjusted equity | | | 115,23 | | | |

ROE [Computed on the basis of an adjusted equity of RON 115 million (assumption provided for 2018 by the Romanian authorities in the notified third restructuring plan); ROCE and ROA computed by dividing net profit by the same relevant aggregate than in Table 6.] | | | | -25 % | -22 % | -20 % | -18 %

ROCE | | | | -20 % | -12 % | -17 % | -7 %

ROA | | | | -7 % | -6 % | -5 % | -4 %