4. ASSESSMENT OF THE AID › 4.3. Compatibility of the aid and the legal basis for the assessment › 4.3.2. Presence of real and actual own contribution free of aid from CNU › 4.3.2.1. Assessment of the revenues from SNN for UO2 provision by CNU, Decision_act (EU) 2020/1012

In forcesince 24 Feb 2020
(126)

The Commission then assessed, other things being equal, what would be the level of CNU’s own contribution if those revenues from SNN for processing were not accounted anymore. The resulting operational cash flows are presented in table 6 [In order to recalculate the operational cash flows, several assumptions on the revenues and the costs as presented by Romania (Table 4) have been made. First, regarding the revenues, the assumption is taken that CNU would not receive the revenues linked to the UO2 contract with SNN as from 2019; revenues from 2017 and 2018 pre-dated law 193/2018. Second, the calculations conservatively assume that CNU would bear only a percentage of the costs related to the Feldioara plant corresponding to the percentage of revenues generated by the scrap contract compared to the total revenues generated by the scrap and the UO2 contract to SNN as of 2019. The operating costs of the existing Crucea-Botușana mine as of 2019 are also set aside, considering that CNU would not bear most of them if it needs not to produce U3O8 for supplying UO2 to SNN. As a result, these operating cash flows constitute a maximum in the absence of UO2 contract with SNN given conservative assumptions on the extent of the decrease in revenues and of the decrease in costs: the decrease in costs could be lower, for instance if CNU were still to produce U3O8 for instance for constituting an internal stock, in spite of the absence of UO2 contract with SNN.].

Table 6

Actual and projected financial results of CNU

Source: Commission calculations based on data in Third restructuring plan.

In RON million | 2017 | 2018 | 2019 (f) | 2020 (f) | 2021 (f) | 2022 (f) | 2023 (f)

Turnover | 84,1 | 37,8 | 12,9 | 15,4 | 16,5 | 16,9 | 17,4

(total expenditures) | 66,0 | 44,0 | 2,7 | 3,2 | 3,1 | 2,8 | 3,0

Total operational cash-flows | 18,1 | -6,2 | 10,1 | 12,2 | 13,4 | 14,1 | 14,4

(amortisations) | | 14,6 | 11,3 | 11,3 | 11,3 | 11,3 | 11,3

(taxes – 16 % tax rate assumed based on submissions by Romania) | | 0,0 | 0,0 | 0,2 | 0,3 | 0,5 | 0,5

Net profit | | n.a. | -1,2 | 0,8 | 1,7 | 2,4 | 2,6

Adjusted equity | | 115,2 [Based on submission by the Romania authorities (RON 41,3 million of ‘share capital’ and RON 73,9 million of ‘other reserves’).] | 114,1 | 114,8 | 116,6 | 119,0 | 121,6

ROE [ROE, ROCE and ROA were computed, in accordance with the methodology followed for the financial year 2018 by the Romanian authorities in their submission dated 19 April 2019 (annex 14), by dividing the net profit by the ‘share capital’ increased by ‘other reserves’. Cumulative profits were taken into account to compute an adjusted equity for each year of the restructuring period.] | | n.a. | -1,0 % | 0,7 % | 1,5 % | 2,0 % | 2,2 %

ROCE | | n.a. | -0,8 % | 0,4 % | 1,3 % | 0,7 % | 0,9 %

ROA | | n.a. | -0,3 % | 0,2 % | 0,4 % | 0,4 % | 0,6 %