82 5. COMMMISSION ASSESSMENT › 5.2. Substantive requirements › 5.2.2. Proportionality, transparency, objective criteria and non-discrimination › 5.2.2.2. Proportionality, transparency and objective criteria, Decision_act (EU) 2019/1585

In forcesince 24 Sep 2019

The study conducted by SEO Amsterdam Economics [Cf. recital 41 above.] concludes that ‘a low transfer thresholds leads to a limited market distortion, while larger thresholds leads to a more selective as well as more effective outcome’. The study takes a 10 % threshold as a starting point and compares the effects of alternative thresholds. Should the TDR refer to this threshold, KLM flights would constitute point-to- point flights to a substantial extend, namely up to almost […] aircraft movements ([…] routes) annually. A very low threshold (4 % or lower) would not yield any major difference for KLM […], while especially leisure carriers would be affected to a substantial extent. Compared to a threshold of 10 %, they would lose opportunities to obtain a priority at Lelystad airport for the purpose of moving traffic there. With a transfer threshold of 8 % or lower, KLM would be affected only moderately compared to the 10 % scenario, i.e. […]. Would the threshold be set at 15 %, KLM would come under the TDR to a considerably greater extent (over […] additional aircraft movements), i.e. in absolute terms beyond all airlines whose home-base is Schiphol Airport. At a 15 % threshold, about […] % of Transavia's flights from Schiphol Airport would qualify as transfer flights, while at a very low threshold, i.e. 2 %, over […] % of Transavia's flights from Schiphol Airport would qualify, implying that the airlines serves a relatively large number of destinations with only a few destinations giving rise to transfer flights. As regards other competitors, the study shows that almost […] % of the traffic generated by Easyjet at Schiphol Airport reaches the 15 % threshold. With a threshold at this level, Tuifly and Corendon would have the least opportunities to obtain a priority at Lelystad airport for the purpose of moving traffic there, among all carriers resorting to Schiphol Airport as home-base.