This sectoral reference document (SRD) is based on a detailed scientific and policy report [The scientific and policy report is publicly available on the JRC-IPTS website at the following address: http://susproc.jrc.ec.europa.eu/activities/emas/documents/FoodBeverageBEMP.pdf The conclusions on best environmental management practices and their applicability as well as the identified specific environmental performance indicators and the benchmarks of excellence contained in this Sectoral Reference Document are based on the findings documented in the scientific and policy report. All the background information and technical details can be found there.] (‘Best Practice Report’) developed by the Institute for Prospective Technological Studies (IPTS), one of the seven institutes of the European Commission's Joint Research Centre (JRC).
The Community eco-management and audit scheme (EMAS) was introduced in 1993, for voluntary participation by organisations, by Council Regulation (EEC) No 1836/93 [Council Regulation (EEC) No 1836/93 of 29 June 1993 allowing voluntary participation by companies in the industrial sector in a Community eco-management and audit scheme (OJ L 168, 10.7.1993, p. 1).]. Subsequently, EMAS has undergone two major revisions:
Regulation (EC) No 761/2001 of the European Parliament and of the Council [Regulation (EC) No 761/2001 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 19 March 2001 allowing voluntary participation by organisations in a Community eco-management and audit scheme (EMAS) (OJ L 114, 24.4.2001, p. 1).],
Regulation (EC) No 1221/2009.
An important new element of the latest revision, which came into force on 11 January 2010, is Article 46 on the development of SRDs. The SRDs have to include best environmental management practices (BEMPs), environmental performance indicators for the specific sectors and, where appropriate, benchmarks of excellence and rating systems identifying performance levels.
The eco-management and audit scheme (EMAS) is a scheme for voluntary participation by organisations committed to continuous environmental improvement. Within this framework, this SRD provides sector-specific guidance to the food and beverage manufacturing sector and points out a number of options for improvement as well as best practices.
The document was written by the European Commission using input from stakeholders. A Technical Working Group, comprising experts and stakeholders of the sector, led by the JRC, discussed and ultimately agreed on the best environmental management practices, sector-specific environmental performance indicators and benchmarks of excellence described in this document; these benchmarks in particular were deemed to be representative of the levels of environmental performance that are achieved by the best performing organisations in the sector.
The SRD aims to help and support all organisations that intend to improve their environmental performance by providing ideas and inspiration as well as practical and technical guidance.
The SRD is primarily addressed to organisations that are already registered with EMAS; secondly to organisations that are considering registering with EMAS in the future; and thirdly to all organisations that wish to learn more about best environmental management practices in order to improve their environmental performance. Consequently, the objective of this document is to support all organisations in the food and beverage manufacturing sector to focus on relevant environmental aspects, both direct and indirect, and to find information on best environmental management practices, as well as appropriate sector-specific environmental performance indicators to measure their environmental performance, and benchmarks of excellence.
Pursuant to Regulation (EC) No 1221/2009, EMAS registered organisations are to take SRDs into account at two different levels:
When developing and implementing their environmental management system in light of the environmental reviews (Article 4(1)(b)):
Organisations should use relevant elements of the SRD when defining and reviewing their environmental targets and objectives in accordance with the relevant environmental aspects identified in the environmental review and policy, as well as when deciding on the actions to implement to improve their environmental performance.
When preparing the environmental statement (Article 4(1)(d) and Article 4(4)):
Organisations should consider the relevant sector-specific environmental performance indicators in the SRD when choosing the indicators [According to Annex IV (B.e.) of the EMAS Regulation, the environmental statement shall contain ‘a summary of the data available on the performance of the organisation against its environmental objectives and targets with respect to its significant environmental impacts. Reporting shall be on the core indicators and on other relevant existing environmental performance indicators as set out in Section C’. Annex IV — Section C states that ‘each organisation shall also report annually on its performance relating to the more specific environmental aspects as identified in its environmental statement and, where available, take account of sectoral reference documents as referred to in Article 46.’] to use for their reporting of environmental performance.
When choosing the set of indicators for reporting, they should take into account the indicators proposed in the corresponding SRD and their relevance with regards to the significant environmental aspects identified by the organisation in its environmental review. Indicators need only be taken into account where relevant to those environmental aspects that are judged as being most significant in the environmental review.
When reporting on environmental performance and on the other factors regarding environmental performance the organisations should mention in the environmental statement how the relevant best environmental management practices and, if available, benchmarks of excellence, have been taken into account.
They should describe how relevant best environmental management practices and benchmarks of excellence (which provide an indication of the environmental performance level that is achieved by best performers) were used to identify measures and actions, and possibly to set priorities, to (further) improve their environmental performance. However, implementing best environmental management practices or meeting the identified benchmarks of excellence is not mandatory, because the voluntary character of EMAS leaves the assessment of the feasibility of the benchmarks and of the implementation of the best practices, in terms of costs and benefits, to the organisations themselves.
Similarly to environmental performance indicators, the relevance and applicability of the best environmental management practices and benchmarks of excellence should be assessed by the organisation according to the significant environmental aspects identified by the organisation in its environmental review, as well as technical and financial aspects.
Elements of SRDs (indicators, BEMPs or benchmarks of excellence) not considered relevant with regards to the significant environmental aspects identified by the organisation in its environmental review should not be reported or described in the environmental statement.
EMAS participation is an ongoing process. Every time an organisation plans to improve its environmental performance (and reviews its environmental performance) it shall consult the SRD on specific topics to find inspiration about which issues to tackle next in a step-wise approach.
EMAS environmental verifiers shall check if and how the SRD was taken into account by the organisation when preparing its environmental statement (Article 18(5)(d) of Regulation (EC) No 1221/2009).
When undertaking an audit, accredited environmental verifiers will need evidence from the organisation of how the relevant elements of the SRD have been selected in light of the environmental review and taken into account. They shall not check compliance with the described benchmarks of excellence, but they shall verify evidence on how the SRD was used as a guide to identify indicators and proper voluntary measures that the organisation can implement to improve its environmental performance.
Given the voluntary nature of EMAS and SRD, no disproportionate burdens should be put on the organisations to provide such evidence. In particular, verifiers shall not require an individual justification for each of the best practices, sector-specific environmental performance indicators and benchmarks of excellence which are mentioned in the SRD and not considered relevant by the organisation in the light of its environmental review. Nevertheless, they could suggest relevant additional elements for the organisation to take into account in the future as further evidence of its commitment to continuous performance improvement.
This document consists of four sections. Section 1 introduces EMAS' legal background and describes how to use this document, while Section 2 defines the scope of this SRD. Section 3 briefly describes the different best environmental management practices (BEMPs) [A detailed description of each of the best practices, with practical guidance on how to implement them, is available in the ‘Best Practice Report’ published by the JRC and available on-line at http://susproc.jrc.ec.europa.eu/activities/emas/documents/FoodBeverageBEMP.pdf Organisations are invited to consult it if interested in learning more about some of the best practices described in this SRD.] together with information on their applicability, in general as well as at SME level. When specific environmental performance indicators and benchmarks of excellence could be formulated for a particular BEMP, these are also given. Some of the indicators and benchmarks are relevant for more than one BEMP and are thus repeated whenever appropriate. Finally, Section 4 presents a comprehensive table with a selection of the most relevant environmental performance indicators, associated explanations and related benchmarks of excellence.
This SRD addresses the environmental performance of the activities of the food and beverage manufacturing sector. In this document, the food and beverage manufacturing sector includes companies belonging to the following NACE code divisions (according to the statistical classification of economic activities established by Regulation (EC) No 1893/2006 of the European Parliament and of the Council [Regulation (EC) No 1893/2006 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 20 December 2006 establishing the statistical classification of economic activities NACE Revision 2 and amending Council Regulation (EEC) No 3037/90 as well as certain EC Regulations on specific statistical domains (OJ L 393, 30.12.2006, p. 1).]):
NACE code 10: manufacture of food products,
NACE code 11: manufacture of beverages.
Best practices presented for the overall food and beverage manufacturing sector (Section 3.1) are addressed to all companies belonging to NACE codes 10 and 11.
The following two tables present the most significant direct and indirect environmental aspects [According to Regulation (EC) No 1221/2009 ‘direct environmental aspect’ refers to an environmental aspect associated with activities, products and services of the organisation itself, over which it has direct management control. Instead ‘indirect environmental aspect’ refers to an environmental aspect which results from the interaction of the organisation with third parties and which can to a reasonable degree be influenced by the organisation.] for food and beverage manufacturers, the related main environmental pressures and how these are tackled in this document. They are addressed either by BEMPs described in Section 3.1 or by making reference to other available reference documents such as the Best Available Techniques (BAT) Reference Document for the Food, Drink and Milk Industries (FDM BREF) [For more information on the content of the Best Available Techniques Reference Documents and full explanation of terms and acronyms, refer to the European Integrated Pollution Prevention and Control Bureau website: http://eippcb.jrc.ec.europa.eu/].
Most significant direct environmental aspects | Related main environmental pressures | BEMPs
Industrial processes and related operations | Emissions to water |
Reference to BAT in FDM BREF
Emissions to air (NOx, SOx, VOCs, particulate matter) |
Reference to BAT in FDM BREF
Solid waste generation |
Reference to BAT in FDM BREF
BEMP on avoiding food waste in food and beverage manufacturing (Section 3.1.9)
Water consumption |
Reference to BAT in FDM BREF
Energy consumption, GHG emissions (CO2) |
BEMP on deploying energy management and energy efficiency throughout all operations (Section 3.1.7)
BEMP on integrating renewable energy in manufacturing processes (Section 3.1.8)
Refrigeration | Energy consumption, GHG emissions (refrigerants) |
BEMP on improving freezing and refrigeration (Section 3.1.6)
Cleaning operations | Water consumption, use of chemicals, waste water generation |
Reference to BAT in FDM BREF
BEMP on environmentally friendly cleaning operations (Section 3.1.4)
Transport and logistics | Energy consumption, GHG emissions, emissions to air (CO2, CO, SO2, NOx, particulate matter etc.) |
BEMP on transport and logistics (Section 3.1.5)
Packaging | GHG emissions, energy consumption, resource depletion (material use) |
Reference to BAT in FDM BREF
BEMP on improving or selecting packaging to minimise environmental impact (Section 3.1.3)
[The Sectoral Reference Document for the agriculture — crop and animal production sector and the related ‘Best Practice Report’ published by the JRC are available online at: http://susproc.jrc.ec.europa.eu/activities/emas/agri.html] [The Sectoral Reference Document for the retail trade sector and the related ‘Best Practice Report’ published by the JRC are available online at: http://susproc.jrc.ec.europa.eu/activities/emas/retail.html]
Most significant indirect environmental aspects | Related main environmental pressures | BEMPs
Supply chain management | GHG emissions, energy consumption, water consumption, emissions to air etc. |
BEMP on sustainable supply chain management (Section 3.1.2)
Agriculture | GHG emissions (CO2, CH4), biodiversity loss, emissions to air, eutrophication, water consumption |
BEMP on sustainable supply chain management (Section 3.1.2)
Reference to the Agriculture — crop and animal production SRD
Packaging | GHG emissions, energy consumption, resource depletion (material use) |
BEMP on improving or selecting packaging to minimise environmental impact (Section 3.1.3)
Transport and logistics | Energy consumption, GHG emissions, emissions to air (CO2, CO, SO2, NOx, particulate matter etc.) |
BEMP on transport and logistics (Section 3.1.5)
Retail | Energy consumption, food waste generation |
Reference to Retail Trade SRD
Food preparation by consumers | Energy consumption, food waste generation |
BEMP on improving or selecting packaging to minimise environmental impact (Section 3.1.3)
Environmental aspects listed in Tables 2.1 and 2.2 were selected as the most significant for the majority of food and beverage manufacturers. However, the environmental aspects to be managed by specific companies, and whether each aspect is direct or indirect for a specific company, should be assessed on a case-by-case basis. Environmental aspects, such as hazardous waste, biodiversity or material use for areas other than those listed above could also be significant.
In addition to the BEMPs listed in Tables 2.1 and 2.2, an overarching BEMP on ‘performing an environmental sustainability assessment of products and/or operations’ can help to improve the environmental performance for all environmental aspects and related pressures presented in the tables.
Moreover, this SRD, apart from describing the best practices for the overall food and beverage manufacturing sector (all companies belonging to NACE codes 10 and 11) listed above, also includes a range of specific best practices for several subsectors, namely:
processing of coffee (NACE code 10.83) in Section 3.2,
manufacture of olive oil (NACE code 10.41) in Section 3.3,
manufacture of soft drinks (NACE code 11.07) in Section 3.4,
manufacture of beer (NACE code 11.05) in Section 3.5,
production of meat and poultry meat products (NACE code 10.13) in Section 3.6,
manufacture of fruit juice (NACE code 10.32) in Section 3.7,
cheese-making operations (NACE code 10.51) in Section 3.8,
manufacture of bread, biscuits and cakes (NACE codes 10.71 and 10.72) in Section 3.9,
manufacture of wine (NACE 11.02) in Section 3.10.
This section targets all food and beverage manufacturers (NACE codes 10 and 11).
BEMP is to assess the environmental impact of products and operations using life-cycle assessment (LCA) tools [With the aim of establishing a common method for measuring life cycle environmental performance, the European Commission developed the Product Environmental Footprint (PEF) and Organisation Environmental Footprint (OEF) methods. The use of these methods was object of a Commission Recommendation in 2013 (http://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX:32013H0179). The development of product- and sector-specific rules is being tested (between 2013 and 2016) by more than 280 volunteering companies and organisations grouped in 26 pilot cases (see list on http://ec.europa.eu/environment/eussd/smgp/ef_pilots.htm).] to identify priority areas for action, or ‘hotspots’, and define a strategy for reducing the environmental impacts.
When undertaking an environmental sustainability assessment, food and beverage manufacturers can face a number of challenges which include the complexity of the product and the accessibility of information; it can be expensive and time-consuming to undertake LCAs, and certain environmental impacts may also be beyond the control of the manufacturer and thus very difficult to act upon, even if they can be quantified.
This BEMP is applicable to SMEs in the food and beverage manufacturing sector, given that they can use simplified tools when their capabilities or resources do not permit full LCAs.
[The percentage of products can be calculated (here and in following similar indicators) by considering the total different types of products manufactured and how many types of products are assessed using a recognised environmental sustainability assessment protocol or by weighting with sales volume each type of product manufactured for example.]
Environmental performance indicators | Benchmarks of excellence
(i1) Percentage of sites or products assessed using a recognised environmental sustainability assessment protocol (%).
(i2) Number of sites or products assessed using a recognised environmental sustainability assessment protocol.
(b1) A company-wide environmental sustainability assessment covering all operations is implemented.
(b2) An environmental sustainability assessment for all new products under development is carried out.
BEMP is to manage the supply chain, in particular ingredients or raw materials, by choosing one or more of the following three approaches:
green procurement, i.e. selecting suppliers that fulfil identified environmental performance criteria [The environmental performance criteria used in green procurement may be based on certifications, standards, ecolabels, private initiatives/cooperation or the results of sustainability assessments (see BEMP 3.1.1) developed internally or externally.],
adapting recipes to remove unsustainable ingredients,
supporting existing suppliers in improving their environmental performance.
Additionally, for those food and beverage manufacturers using substantial amounts of water as an ingredient (e.g. beverage manufacturers), it is BEMP to firstly assess the risks posed, by the production site, to the local water resources. Afterwards, a water resource sustainability programme can be put in place, detailing specific actions that can be taken to support the preservation of the local water resources.
Sustainable supply chain management can have some limitations: (i) the green procurement approach assumes that ‘green’ choices are available; (ii) recipes can be adapted if unsustainable ingredients can be removed with equivalent, more sustainable alternatives; and (iii) it may not always be possible to influence the performance of existing suppliers, e.g. due to small volumes of products purchased by an SME. However, the three approaches presented are in most cases broadly applicable.
This BEMP, with the aforementioned limitations, is fully applicable to SMEs in the food and beverage manufacturing sector.
Environmental performance indicators | Benchmarks of excellence
(i3) Percentage of ingredients or products (e.g. packaging) meeting the company's specific sustainability criteria or complying with existing sustainability standards (% by number or value in EUR)
(i4) Percentage of ingredients or products (e.g. packaging) sourced via green procurement (% by number or value in EUR)
(i5) Percentage of suppliers engaged in sustainability improvement programmes (% by number of suppliers or value in EUR of products they supply)
(i6) Percentage of suppliers with environmental management systems in place (% by number of suppliers or value in EUR of products they supply)
—
BEMP is to minimise the environmental impact of packaging (i.e. primary, secondary and tertiary packaging), throughout the product life cycle, for example by the use of:
eco-design tools to simulate the environmental performance of the packaging during the design,
‘lightweighting’, i.e. packaging with reduced weight but the same protective performance,
bulk packaging of ingredients delivered by suppliers to the company,
refills, e.g. refillable packaging to be returned to the food and beverage manufacturer,
returnable secondary and tertiary packaging,
packaging containing recycled material,
packaging containing bio plastics provided that the environmental benefits of this choice can be proven.
Furthermore, BEMP is for food and beverage manufacturers to help consumers reducing the food waste they generate, by:
using modified atmosphere packaging to increase shelf-life of products,
identifying the optimum portion size of the packaging with a view to better cater for different lifestyles and households to reduce leftovers,
including messages on packaging recommending optimised storage of the food product to avoid its spoilage.
This BEMP is applicable to all food and beverage manufacturers including SMEs.