The elements mentioned in recital 93 above are not mere assumptions and allegations, but facts which were as such not questioned by the company. In addition, these facts were presented to the company in the Article 28 letter of 3 December 2015, in which the company was invited to comment. Subsequently, the findings were disclosed to the company on 22 December 2015, on which the company again was invited to comment. Accordingly, the rights of defence of the company were fully respected. The fact remains that the company at least attempted to minimise, if not to hide, its commercial ties, including the existence of its brand usage authorisation agreement, with the Chinese company during the verification visit. Indeed the Malaysian company referred during the on spot verification to a brand usage of the Chinese company, however mentioning explicitly ‘for a limited period’. The brand usage contract was neither provided nor was it revealed on spot that this agreement had been renewed for another 4 years. None of the elements mentioned above in recital 93, which showed strong commercial ties between the two companies, were explained in detail or shown to the Commission services during the verification visit. Also, the accuracy of these elements was not questioned by the company.
98 4. REQUESTS FOR EXEMPTION, Regulation (EU) 2016/184
In forcesince 11 Feb 2016