90 4. COMMENTS FROM BELGIUM › 4.2. Comments from Belgium on misconceptions in the Opening Decision › 4.2.5. Recovery, Decision_act (EU) 2016/1699

In forcesince 11 Jan 2016

Belgium argues that recovery would in any case be prevented by the principles of legal certainty and legitimate expectations [See Joined Cases C-182/03 and C-217/03 Belgium and Forum 187 ASBL v Commission ECLI:EU:C:2006:416, paragraphs 69 and 147.], since previous Commission decisions on transfer pricing and State aid have led it to believe that there can be no State aid involved if Member States adhere to the arm's length principle [Ibid.], considering that there is no harmonised legislation in this area in the Union. Moreover, Belgium refers to conclusions by the Council of Ministers on the Code of Conduct for business taxation [See ECOFIN Presidency's conclusions of 19 March 2003, referring to the Code of Conduct Group's report with reference 7018/1/03 FISC 31 REV 1, available here: http://www.consilium.europa.eu/uedocs/cms_data/docs/pressdata/en/ecofin/75013.pdf] concerning another scheme purportedly based on the same principles as the Excess Profit exemption [The so-called informal capital ruling scheme, referred to as scheme E002 in the Code of Conduct documents.] and the fact that the Commission did not raise any State aid issue against the Excess Profit exemption scheme until 10 years after the termination of the informal capital ruling scheme. Finally, recovery would lead to exceptional complexity and double taxation and unequal treatment between Belgium and other Member States that also have a ruling practice.

  • Judgment of the Court (Second Chamber) of 22 June 2006. Kingdom of Belgium (C-182/03) and Forum 187 ASBL (C-217/03) v Commission of the EuroDecision

    22 Jun 2006 · 62003CJ0182