The Commission further observes that according to the decisions cited by Belgium, the Commission has previously concluded that a deviation from the arm's length principle for determining a group entity's taxable profit will constitute State aid where it leads to a reduction of that entity's tax liability under the ordinary system of taxation of corporate profits [See Commission Decision of 11 July 2001 in Case C 47/2001 (ex NN 42/2000) — Germany: Control and coordination centres of foreign companies (OJ C 304, 30.10.2001, p. 2). Decision 2003/501/EC.]. In addition, the Commission recalls that it clearly concluded in the context of its investigation into the new Coordination Centres scheme proposed by Belgium that profit accrued to a Belgian entity in excess of a profit determined according to a cost plus method should be subject to tax in Belgium even though the cost plus method led to a profit deemed to be at arm's length [See Commission Decision 2005/378/EC of 8 September 2004 concerning the aid scheme which Belgium is proposing to implement for coordination centres (OJ L 125, 18.5.2005, p. 10), a.o., recitals 22, 34 and 37 as well as Article 1, point (b).]. That conclusion has been confirmed by the Court of Justice [Joined Cases C-182/03 and C-217/03 Belgium and Forum 187 ASBL v Commission ECLI:EU:C:2006:416.]. Considering that the Excess Profit exemption scheme constitutes a deviation from the arm's length principle, as demonstrated in Section 6.3.2.2, Belgium cannot rely on those decisions to claim that recovery would be contrary to the general principle of legal certainty. On the contrary, Belgium should have been aware that a tax scheme that leads to a favourable treatment for the beneficiaries under that scheme in terms of artificially lowering their tax base, could lead to a violation of the State aid rules and should therefore, in case of doubt, have notified the contested scheme to the Commission before putting it into effect.
201 7. RECOVERY › 7.1. Legitimate expectations and legal certainty, Decision_act (EU) 2016/1699
In forcesince 11 Jan 2016cited 1×
Judgment of the General Court (Second Chamber, Extended Composition) of 20 September 2023. St. Jude Medical Coordination Center (SJM CoordinDecision
The eighth plea alleges breach of the principles of legal certainty and legality in so far as, in recitals 200 to 204 of the contested decision, the Commission stated that it was not bound by its previous decision-making practice in its …
20 Sep 2023 · 62016TJ0420
Judgment of the Court (Second Chamber) of 22 June 2006. Kingdom of Belgium (C-182/03) and Forum 187 ASBL (C-217/03) v Commission of the EuroDecision
22 Jun 2006 · 62003CJ0182
- celex=31947D2001