198 7. RECOVERY › 7.1. Legitimate expectations and legal certainty, Decision_act (EU) 2016/1699

In forcesince 11 Jan 2016

As regards Belgium's reliance on the principle of legitimate expectations, the Commission recalls that, according to the case-law of the Union courts [See Case C-5/89 Commission v Germany, ECLI:EU:C:1990:320, paragraph 17, and Case C-310/99 Italy v Commission ECLI:EU:C:2002:143, paragraph 104.], a Member State whose authorities have granted aid in breach of the procedural rules laid down in Article 108(3) of the Treaty may not plead the legitimate expectations of an aid beneficiary to justify a failure to comply with the obligation to take the steps necessary to implement a Commission decision instructing it to recover the aid. If it were allowed to do so, Articles 107 and 108 of the Treaty would be deprived of all practical force, since national authorities would thus be able to rely on their own unlawful conduct to render decisions taken by the Commission under those provisions of the Treaty ineffective. Thus, it is not for the Member State concerned, but for the recipient undertaking, to invoke the existence of exceptional circumstances on the basis of which it had entertained legitimate expectations, leading it to decline to repay the unlawful aid [See Case T-67/94 Ladbroke Racing v Commission ECLI:EU:T:1998:7, paragraph 183; See also Joined Cases T-116/01 and T-118/01, P&O European Ferries (Vizcaya) SA and Diputacion Floral de Vizcaya v Commission ECLI:EU:T:2003:217, paragraph 203.]. Since none of the beneficiaries of the contested scheme claimed a legitimate expectation as to the lawfulness of that scheme, the Commission considers Belgium's reliance on that principle ineffective for the purposes of recovery under the present Decision.

  • Judgment of the Court of First Instance (First Chamber, extended composition) of 5 August 2003. P & O European Ferries (Vizcaya), SA (T-116/Decision

    5 Aug 2003 · 62001TJ0116

  • Judgment of the Court of 20 September 1990. Commission of the European Communities v Federal Republic of Germany.Decision

    20 Sep 1990 · 61989CJ0005

  • Judgment of the Court of First Instance (Second Chamber, extended composition) of 27 January 1998. Ladbroke Racing Ltd v Commission of the EDecision

    27 Jan 1998 · 61994TJ0067

  • Judgment of the Court (Sixth Chamber) of 7 March 2002. Italian Republic v Commission of the European Communities.Decision

    7 Mar 2002 · 61999CJ0310

  • Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union108107Law

  • Judgment of the Court (Third Chamber) of 19 February 2004. Commission of the European Communities v Grand Duchy of Luxemburg.Decision

    19 Feb 2004 · 62003CJ0310

  • case:eu=T-310/99
  • celex=31967D0094
  • ecli=ECLI:EU:T:2002:143