The absence of any requirement to demonstrate the inclusion of the same profit in the tax base of both associated companies (one abroad, one in Belgium) is an important element distinguishing rulings granting the Excess Profit exemption from other transfer pricing rulings authorising a downward transfer pricing adjustment pursuant to Article 185(2)(b) WIB 92. For the latter type of rulings, the downward adjustment responds to a situation in which the profit recorded in Belgium and exempted has also been declared as taxable profit by an associated group entity in another tax jurisdiction or where a primary upward adjustment was carried out by a foreign tax administration on the taxable profit of that associated foreign entity [The Commission observes that Belgium has provided three examples of rulings based on Article 185(2)(b) WIB 92 which indeed aim at solving actual situations of double taxation (see recital 67). Those rulings are, however, clearly different from the rulings granting the Excess Profit exemption. Indeed, for rulings authorising a downward transfer pricing adjustment, the downward adjustment will lead to a symmetric recording of profit in the accounts of companies involved in the controlled transaction. A downward adjustment of the tax base would therefore be justified by the nature and general scheme of the tax system and therefore not amount to State aid provided it is motivated by the desire to compensate for an upward adjustment in another tax jurisdiction. The Excess Profit exemption, by contrast, cannot be justified on similar grounds, because of the absence of another tax jurisdiction claiming the profit, so that double taxation concerns do not arise.]. By contrast, the Excess Profit exemption provides a unilateral exemption granted in advance that does not require the exempted profit to have been or to be included in the tax base of an associated foreign group entity in another tax jurisdiction, nor that that profit is effectively taxed by that jurisdiction.
174 6. ASSESSMENT › 6.3. Existence of a selective advantage › 6.3.3. Absence of a justification by the nature and general scheme of the tax system, Decision_act (EU) 2016/1699
Judgment of the General Court (Second Chamber, Extended Composition) of 20 September 2023. Atlas Copco Airpower and Others v European CommisDecision
It should be noted that, in recitals 173 to 181 of the contested decision, the Commission concluded, in essence, that the Kingdom of Belgium had not been able to establish that the measures at issue actually served the purpose of avoiding …
20 Sep 2023 · 62016TJ0278
Judgment of the General Court (Second Chamber, Extended Composition) of 20 September 2023. St. Jude Medical Coordination Center (SJM CoordinDecision
It should be noted that, in recitals 173 to 181 of the contested decision, the Commission concluded, in essence, that the Kingdom of Belgium had not been able to establish that the measures at issue were actually aimed at avoiding double …
20 Sep 2023 · 62016TJ0420
Judgment of the General Court (Second Chamber, Extended Composition) of 20 September 2023. Flir Systems Trading Belgium and Henkel Belgium, Decision
It should be noted that, in recitals 173 to 181 of the contested decision, the Commission concluded, in essence, that the Kingdom of Belgium had not been able to establish that the measures at issue actually served the purpose of avoiding …
20 Sep 2023 · 62016TJ0467
Judgment of the General Court (Second Chamber, Extended Composition) of 20 September 2023. Capsugel Belgium and Others v European CommissionDecision
In that regard, it must be noted that, in recitals 173 to 181 of the contested decision, the Commission concluded, in essence, that the Kingdom of Belgium had not been able to establish that the measures at issue actually served the …
20 Sep 2023 · 62016TJ0266
Arrêt du Tribunal (deuxième chambre élargie) du 20 septembre 2023. Soudal NV e.a. contre Commission européenne.Decision
Il convient de constater que, aux considérants 173 à 181 de la décision attaquée, la Commission a conclu, en substance, que le Royaume de Belgique n’était pas parvenu à établir que les mesures en cause poursuivaient réellement …
20 Sep 2023 · 62016TJ0201
Judgment of the General Court (Second Chamber, Extended Composition) of 20 September 2023. Kingdom of Belgium v European Commission.Decision
It should be noted that, in recitals 173 to 181 of the contested decision, the Commission concluded, in essence, that the Kingdom of Belgium had not been able to establish that the measures at issue actually served the purpose of avoiding …
20 Sep 2023 · 62016TJ0131(01)