172 6. ASSESSMENT › 6.3. Existence of a selective advantage › 6.3.3. Absence of a justification by the nature and general scheme of the tax system, Decision_act (EU) 2016/1699

In forcesince 11 Jan 2016cited 1×

Belgium considers the contested scheme justified to prevent potential double taxation. Double taxation refers to situations in which the same profit is taxed twice in respect of the same taxpayer (also referred to as legal double taxation) or in respect of two different taxpayers (i.e. economic double taxation). While the need to avoid double taxation may constitute a possible justification for derogating from the ordinary corporate income tax system [See, by way of analogy, Joined Cases C-78/08 to C-80/08 Paint Graphos ECLI:EU:C:2011:550, paragraph 71, in which the Court referred to the possibility of relying on the nature or general scheme of the national tax system as a justification for the fact that cooperative societies which distribute all their profits to their members are not taxed themselves as cooperatives, provided that tax is levied on the individual members.], Belgium has not demonstrated that the contested scheme actually serves that purpose. Belgium has even acknowledged that the scheme is not meant to reduce or remedy actual double taxation, but only potential double taxation [See recital 89.]. Consequently, the Excess Profit exemption cannot be said to derive directly from the intrinsic basic or guiding principles of the reference system or to be the result of inherent mechanisms necessary for the functioning and effectiveness of that system.

  • Judgment of the General Court (Second Chamber, Extended Composition) of 20 September 2023. Flir Systems Trading Belgium and Henkel Belgium, Decision

    In addition, the applicants have not adduced any evidence that the Kingdom of Belgium has succeeded in demonstrating that the excess profit system was justified on account of disparities arising from national tax rules. As is apparent from …

    20 Sep 2023 · 62016TJ0467