Second, to benefit from the Excess Profit exemption under the contested scheme the prior authorisation of the Ruling Commission by way of an advance ruling is needed, which can only be obtained in respect of future situations or operations that have not yet had tax effects, not for existing situations. This results from the fact that the advance ruling system, introduced into the Belgian tax code by the Law of 24 December 2002, contains the rule that a ruling can only be granted with respect to ‘a special situation or arrangement that has not yet had tax consequences’ for the taxpayer concerned [See recital 44.]. More precisely, a taxpayer is not eligible to apply for a ruling covering the tax implications of its current situation, only the tax implications of a ‘new situation’ can be covered by an advance ruling. Those conditions equally apply to rulings granting an Excess Profit exemption under the contested scheme. Indeed, in the sample of rulings granting an Excess Profit exemption that the Commission has analysed, each ruling contained references to substantial investments and/or the creation of employment and/or the relocation of activities to Belgium [See decision of 26 February 2013 in file 2011.569, § 42: ‘Le programme d'investissement lié à ces projets est le suivant: (…) mise en place d'une troisième ligne de production: investissement de USD 2,2 millions (…) mise en place d'une quatrième et cinquième ligne de production: complément d'investissement d'au moins USD 5 millions (…)’; §43: ‘En terme de création d'emplois, de tels investissements devraient résulter en une augmentation du nombre de travailleurs du groupe en Belgique d'au-moins 30 à 40 équivalents temps plein’;, §83: ‘(…) (La demandeuse) s'engage à augmenter ses capacités de production en Belgique. (…)’ and §91: ‘(la demandeuse) réalisera un bénéfice supérieur en Belgique du fait des économies d'échelles et des synergies dont elle bénéficiera en raison de l'augmentation de sa capacité de production suite à la décision d'investissement additionnel par le groupe’; decision of 30 January 2007 in file 600.460, §15: ‘(…) the business intends to relocate the Central Entrepreneur company from (abroad) to Belgium in the course of 2007’; §18: ‘The Entrepreneur activities that are currntly carried out (abroad) require the employment of 15 positions. All these positions will be transferred to Belgium’.; decision of 15 December 2005 in file 500.249 §6: ‘De totale investering bedroeg circa EUR 109,5 miljoen. De geraamde extra banentoename als gevolg van deze nieuwe investering (…) wordt geraamd op 25 mensen’.; decision of 10 December 2013 in file 2013.540, Section 2: Impact sur le niveau d'emploi en Belgique (…) §68: ‘Grâce à la création de la centrale d'achat et du bureau de qualité en Belgique, 20 nouveaux emplois pourront être créés ou préservés en Belgique. Le recrutement de 4 personnes supplémentaires est également envisagé à moyen terme, après 2015.’ §69: ‘(…) le nombre de points de vente en Belgique ainsi que la surface commerciale (…) devraient augmenter. On peut dès lors s'attendre à la création d'emplois supplémentaires dans le réseau belge de distribution.’ §70: ‘Il convient également de mettre en évidence (qu')en cas de faillite le nombre d'emplois perdus au sein de (l'entreprise reprise).se serait élevé à (…) 300 équivalents temps plein.’ § 71-72: ‘Il est à noter que (la demandeuse) envisage également (…) de créer un nouvel entrepôt de stockage (…) ce qui conduirait à la création de nouveaux emplois’.]. Those elements are not explicitly listed as conditions for the granting of the Excess Profit exemption under Article 185(2)(b) WIB 92, but do constitute key elements to be eligible for an advance ruling, which is compulsory for the application of the Excess Profit exemption. The ‘new situation’-requirement caused by the requirement to apply for a ruling in advance to benefit from the Excess Profit exemption [For rulings other than those concerning the application of the Excess Profit exemption, this requirement would not raise selectivity concerns. Normal rulings merely provide legal certainty for a tax treatment under rules that are equally applicable to all companies, with or without a ruling. Consequently, outside the Excess Profit exemption, in principle the profit subject to tax will be the same whether agreed ex ante in a ruling or ex post in a tax return. The ruling granting the Excess Profit exemption, however, effectively works as a prior authorisation. By law, the discount for excess profit allegedly exceeding the arm's length profit must be established via a ruling and cannot be claimed ex post in a tax return. As a consequence, a company actually recording high (excess) profit in its normal course of business cannot benefit from the Excess Profit exemption. As a result two companies in the same legal and factual situation, where this situation in one case arises from a restructuring and in another case follows the normal course of business will be treated differently because only the first company is eligible to apply for a ruling granting an Excess Profit exemption.], therefore results in de jure selectivity between multinational groups that amend their business model by establishing new operations in Belgium and any other economic operator (including multinational groups) that continue to operate under existing business models in Belgium.
139 6. ASSESSMENT › 6.3. Existence of a selective advantage › 6.3.2. The Excess Profit exemption is a derogation from the reference system › 6.3.2.1. The contested scheme grants a selective advantage to its beneficiaries by derogating from the general Belgian corporate income tax system,, Decision_act (EU) 2016/1699
The 10 that are cited most themselves, of 12.
Judgment of the General Court (Seventh Chamber, Extended Composition) of 14 February 2019. Kingdom of Belgium v European Commission.Decision
In that regard and primarily (recitals 135 to 143 of the contested decision), the Commission considered that the scheme at issue was selective, first of all, because it was available only to entities that were part of a multinational …
14 Feb 2019 · 62016TJ0131
Judgment of the General Court (Second Chamber, Extended Composition) of 20 September 2023. Dow Silicones Corp., anciennement Dow Corning CorDecision
Next, the actual analysis of the selectivity of that advantage is set out in recitals 136 to 141 of the contested decision, under Section 6.3.2.1, so far as concerns the Commission’s primary line of reasoning as to selectivity, based on …
20 Sep 2023 · 62016TJ0858
Judgment of the General Court (Second Chamber, Extended Composition) of 20 September 2023. ZF CV Systems Europe, anciennement Wabco Europe vDecision
As regards the Commission’s finding that the scheme at issue differentiates between the beneficiaries of the exemptions and other operators who are in a comparable situation, it should be noted that, in recitals 138 to 140 of the …
20 Sep 2023 · 62016TJ0637
Judgment of the General Court (Second Chamber, Extended Composition) of 20 September 2023. Atlas Copco Airpower and Others v European CommisDecision
The Commission then went on, in recitals 137 to 141 of the contested decision, to develop its reasons for considering that the scheme at issue differentiated between operators who, in the light of the objective assigned to the Belgian tax …
20 Sep 2023 · 62016TJ0278
Judgment of the General Court (Second Chamber, Extended Composition) of 20 September 2023. St. Jude Medical Coordination Center (SJM CoordinDecision
The Commission then went on, in recitals 137 to 141 of the contested decision, to develop its reasons for considering that the scheme at issue differentiated between operators who, in the light of the objective assigned to the Belgian tax …
20 Sep 2023 · 62016TJ0420
Judgment of the General Court (Second Chamber, Extended Composition) of 20 September 2023. Flir Systems Trading Belgium and Henkel Belgium, Decision
The Commission then went on, in recitals 137 to 141 of the contested decision, to develop its reasons for considering that the scheme at issue differentiated between operators who, in the light of the objective assigned to the Belgian tax …
20 Sep 2023 · 62016TJ0467
Judgment of the General Court (Second Chamber, Extended Composition) of 20 September 2023. Victaulic Europe v European Commission.Decision
Next, the actual analysis of the selectivity of that advantage is set out in recitals 136 to 141 of the contested decision, under Section 6.3.2.1 of that decision, so far as concerns the Commission’s primary line of reasoning as to …
20 Sep 2023 · 62016TJ0373
Judgment of the General Court (Second Chamber, Extended Composition) of 20 September 2023. Magnetrol International and Others v European ComDecision
In that regard, it should be noted that, in recitals 138 to 140 of the contested decision, the Commission put forward three alternative grounds for its conclusion. It is appropriate to examine each of these in turn, for the sake of …
20 Sep 2023 · 62016TJ0263(01)
Opinion of Advocate General Kokott delivered on 3 December 2020. European Commission v Kingdom of Belgium and Magnetrol International.Decision
By the third part of the ground of appeal, the Commission complains that the General Court misinterpreted the third condition of Article 1(d) of Regulation 2015/1589, namely the general and abstract definition of beneficiaries, and …
3 Dec 2020 · 62019CC0337
Judgment of the General Court (Second Chamber, Extended Composition) of 20 September 2023. Capsugel Belgium and Others v European CommissionDecision
In recital 139 of the contested decision, the Commission stated that the scheme at issue was selective in so far as it was not open to companies that may have decided not to make investments, create employment or centralise activities in …
20 Sep 2023 · 62016TJ0266
- celex=31930D0001