By selecting directly the terrestrial platform, Astra considers that the measure, including the ongoing aid for O&M, violates the principle of technological neutrality. It emphasises that satellite transmission would have been cheaper than DTT in Area II [Astra refers to its internal cost study submitted together with the complaint, carried out in November 2008. The study compares the costs of extension of coverage using both technologies — terrestrial and satellite. The assumptions of the study differ from the ones carried out by Spain and Abertis in various respects, amongst others concerning the costs of satellite antenna and necessity of purchase of an external set-up box for the reception of digital terrestrial TV. The study concludes that the extension of coverage via satellite would not be more expensive than using the terrestrial technology.]. This had been demonstrated clearly by Astra's success in the Cantabria tender. Given its significant economies of scale, the satellite solution would have allowed even more cost savings if several regions had coordinated their selection of a platform in Area II. Even if for constitutional reasons the Spanish government could not have imposed that cross-regional synergies be taken into account as a condition for the granting of the funds, the regions could have done so themselves. Only by doing so the regional governments could have ensured that they would choose the most cost-efficient solution for their taxpayers.
81 4. COMMENTS FROM INTERESTED PARTIES › 4.2. COMMENTS FROM ASTRA, Decision_act (EU) 2016/1385
In forcesince 1 Oct 2014