171 5. LEGAL ASSESSMENT › 5.3. COMPATIBILITY ASSESSMENT › 5.3.2. Article 107(3)(c) TFEU › 5.3.2.2. Well-designed aid › Appropriateness and proportionality of the measure, Decision_act (EU) 2016/1385

In forcesince 1 Oct 2014

Spain proposed two other arguments why satellite transmission would be more expensive than DTT. First, in their agreements with content providers, broadcasters have territorial restrictions. To ensure such conditional access would be more expensive for satellite technology. Second, satellite technology would not be equipped to broadcast a large number of regional channels. These allegations have not been substantiated and are contradicted by the fact that Astra's Cantabria contract contained a professional system of conditional access. Moreover, according to Astra's cost calculations, the satellite technology would still be cheaper even if it had to enter into separate agreements with each of the Spanish regions. As regards the regional broadcasting, Astra maintains that the Spanish government's number of 1380 channels is hugely inflated [According to Astra's estimations, the total number of local channels actually broadcasted is limited to 415 channels.]. Again, according to its own calculations, the satellite option would be cheaper even if regional and local channels were included.