The estimates of the study are not robust. By using Castilla-La Mancha's own (even if updated) figures, the initial cost advantage of the DTT network diminished, or, in some scenarios even turned around into an advantage for the satellite platform [If one takes into account updated figures, according to the Commission's own calculations, one obtains a shift in both cost scenarios, with an optimistic estimation of EUR 36466648 for the satellite mode and EUR 60542411for the terrestrial mode, and a pessimistic estimation of EUR 56760211 for the satellite mode and EUR 65155166 for the terrestrial mode. These calculations are based on three elements which have complemented the CLM study: (1) the consideration of the NPV approach to recurrent costs over a 10-year horizon, (2) the number of new transmission sites to guarantee the expected additional coverage and (3) the corrected level of O&M costs. The distinction between ‘optimistic’ and ‘pessimistic’ scenarios follows from the original CLM study.]. This does not yet take into account the possibility of discounts offered by a satellite operator in a competitive tender procedure. On the basis of the above considerations, the study therefore does not provide sufficient evidence to justify the ex ante choice of the DTT technology and refraining from an open tendering procedure.
161 5. LEGAL ASSESSMENT › 5.3. COMPATIBILITY ASSESSMENT › 5.3.2. Article 107(3)(c) TFEU › 5.3.2.2. Well-designed aid › Conclusion, Decision_act (EU) 2016/1385
In forcesince 1 Oct 2014