1 ANNEX, Decision_act (EU) 2016/611

In forcesince 15 Apr 2016

This document is a Sectoral Reference Document (SRD) established according to Article 46 of Regulation (EC) No 1221/2009 on the voluntary participation by organisations in a Community eco-management and audit scheme (EMAS) [OJ L 342, 22.12.2009, p. 1.]. With a view to facilitating the understanding of this SRD, this introduction provides an outline of its legal background and its use.

The SRD is based on a detailed scientific and policy report [The scientific and policy report is publicly available on the JRC/IPTS website at the following address: http://susproc.jrc.ec.europa.eu/activities/emas/documents/TourismBEMP.pdf. The conclusions on best environmental management practices and their applicability as well as the identified specific environmental performance indicators and the benchmarks of excellence contained in this Sectoral Reference Document are based on the findings documented in the scientific and policy report. All the background information and technical details can be found there.] (‘Best Practice Report’) developed by the Institute for Prospective Technological Studies (IPTS), one of the seven institutes of the European Commission's Joint Research Centre (JRC).

The Community eco-management and audit scheme (EMAS) was introduced in 1993, for voluntary participation by organisations, by Council Regulation (EEC) No 1836/93 [Council Regulation (EEC) No 1836/93 of 29 June 1993 allowing voluntary participation by companies in the industrial sector in a Community eco-management and audit scheme (OJ L 168, 10.7.1993, p. 1).]. Subsequently, EMAS has undergone two major revisions:

Regulation (EC) No 761/2001 of the European Parliament and of the Council [Regulation (EC) No 761/2001 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 19 March 2001 allowing voluntary participation by organisations in a Community eco-management and audit scheme (EMAS) (OJ L 114, 24.4.2001, p. 1).],

Regulation (EC) No 1221/2009.

An important new element of the latest revision, which came into force on 11 January 2010, is Article 46 on the development of Sectoral Reference Documents (SRDs). The SRDs have to include Best Environmental Management Practices (BEMPs), Environmental Performance Indicators for specific sectors and, where appropriate, Benchmarks of Excellence and rating systems identifying performance levels.

The eco-management and audit scheme (EMAS) is a scheme for voluntary participation by organisations committed to continuous environmental improvement. Within this framework, this Sectoral Reference Document (SRD) provides sector-specific guidance to the tourism sector and points out a number of options for improvement as well as best practices.

The document was written by the European Commission's Joint Research Centre using input from stakeholders. A Technical Working Group, comprising experts and stakeholders of the sector, led by the European Commission's Joint Research Centre, discussed and ultimately agreed on the Best Environmental Management Practices, sector-specific Environmental Performance Indicators and Benchmarks of Excellence described in this document; these benchmarks in particular were deemed to be representative of the levels of environmental performance that are achieved by the best performing organisations in the sector.

The SRD aims to help and support all organisations that intend to improve their environmental performance by providing ideas and inspiration as well as practical and technical guidance.

This SRD is primarily addressed to organisations that are already registered with EMAS; secondly to organisations that are considering registering with EMAS in the future; and thirdly to all organisations that wish to learn more about best environmental management practices in order to improve their environmental performance. Consequently, the objective of this document is to support all organisations and actors in the tourism sector to focus on relevant environmental aspects, both direct and indirect, and to find information on Best Practices, appropriate sector-specific Environmental Performance Indicators to measure their environmental performance, and Benchmarks of Excellence.

According to Regulation (EC) No 1221/2009, EMAS registered organisations shall take SRDs into account at two different levels:

(1)

When developing and implementing their environmental management system in light of the Environmental Reviews (Article 4.1b);

This means that organisations should use relevant elements of the SRD when defining and reviewing their environmental targets and objectives in accordance with the relevant environmental aspects identified in the Environmental Review and policy, as well as when deciding on the actions to implement to improve their environmental performance.

(2)

When preparing the Environmental Statement (Article 4.1d and Article 4.4).

This means that:

(a)

Organisations should consider the relevant sector-specific Environmental Performance Indicators in the SRD when choosing the indicators [According to Annex IV (B.e.) of the EMAS Regulation, the environmental statement shall contain ‘a summary of the data available on the performance of the organisation against its environmental objectives and targets with respect to its significant environmental impacts. Reporting shall be on the core indicators and on other relevant existing environmental performance indicators as set out in Section C’. Annex IV — Section C states that ‘each organisation shall also report annually on its performance relating to the more specific environmental aspects as identified in its environmental statement and, where available, take account of sectoral reference documents as referred to in Article 46’.] to use for their reporting of environmental performance.

When choosing the set of indicators for reporting, they should take into account the indicators proposed in the corresponding SRD and their relevance with regards to the significant environmental aspects identified by the organisation in its Environmental Review. Indicators need only be taken into account if relevant to those environmental aspects that are judged as being most significant in the Environmental Review.

(b)

Organisations should mention in the Environmental Statement how the relevant Best Environmental Management Practices and, if available, Benchmarks of Excellence, have been taken into account.

They should describe how relevant Best Environmental Management Practices and Benchmarks of Excellence (which provide an indication of the environmental performance level that is achieved by best performers) were used to identify measures and actions, and possibly to set priorities, to (further) improve their environmental performance. However, implementing Best Environmental Management Practices or meeting the identified Benchmarks of Excellence is not mandatory, because the voluntary character of EMAS leaves the assessment of the feasibility of the benchmarks and of the implementation of the best practices, in terms of costs and benefits, to the organisations themselves.

Similarly to Environmental Performance Indicators, the relevance and applicability of the Best Environmental Management Practices and Benchmarks of Excellence should be assessed by the organisation according to the significant environmental aspects identified by the organisation in its Environmental Review, as well as technical and financial aspects.

Elements of SRDs (indicators, BEMPs or Benchmark of Excellence) not considered relevant with regards to the significant environmental aspects identified by the organisation in its Environmental Review should not be reported or described in the environmental statement.

EMAS participation is an ongoing process. This means that every time an organisation plans to improve its environmental performance (and reviews its environmental performance) it shall consult the SRD on specific topics to find inspiration about which issues to tackle next in a step-wise approach.

EMAS environmental verifiers shall check if and how the SRD was taken into account by the organisation when preparing its Environmental Statement (Article 18(5)(d) of Regulation (EC) No 1221/2009).

This means that, when undertaking an audit, accredited environmental verifiers will need evidence from the organisation of how the relevant elements of the SRD have been selected in light of the Environmental Reviews and taken into account. They shall not check compliance with the described benchmarks of excellence, but they shall verify evidence on how the SRD was used as a guide to identify indicators and proper voluntary measures that the organisation can implement to improve its environmental performance.

Given the voluntary nature of EMAS and SRD, no disproportionate burdens should be put on the organisations to provide such evidence. In particular, verifiers shall not require an individual justification for each of the best practices, sector-specific Environmental Performance Indicators and Benchmarks of Excellence which are mentioned in the SRD and not considered relevant by the organisation in light of its Environmental Review. Nevertheless, they could suggest relevant additional elements for the organisation to take into account in the future as further evidence of its commitment to continuous performance improvement.

This document consists of four chapters. Chapter 1 introduces EMAS' legal background and describes how to use this document, while Chapter 2 defines the scope of this SRD. Chapter 3 briefly describes the different Best Environmental Management Practices (BEMPs) together with information on their applicability, in general as well as at SME level. When specific Environmental Performance Indicators and Benchmarks of Excellence could be formulated for a particular BEMP, these are also given. Some of the indicators and benchmarks are relevant for more than one BEMP and are thus repeated whenever appropriate.

Finally, Chapter 4 presents a comprehensive table with a selection of the most relevant Environmental Performance Indicators, associated explanations and related Benchmarks of Excellence.

This document addresses some of the activities specified in section I 55-56 ‘Accommodation and Food Service Activities’, section N 79 ‘Travel agency, tour operator reservation service and related activities’ and section O 84.11 ‘General Public Administration Activities’ of Annex I to Regulation (EC) No 1893/2006 of the European Parliament and of the Council [Regulation (EC) No 1893/2006 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 20 December 2006 establishing the statistical classification of economic activities NACE Revision 2 and amending Council Regulation (EEC) No 3037/90 as well as certain EC Regulations on specific statistical domains (OJ L 393, 30.12.2006, p. 1).] (NACE Rev.2).

This sectoral reference document (SRD) primarily covers Best Environmental Management Practices within organisations that provide accommodation, food and beverage services, or that manage tourism destinations or offer and reserve travel, accommodation or activities for tourism (travel agents and tour operators) [This document does not directly target the cruise sector. However, a number of the BEMPs described may, to a certain extent, be also applicable to cruises.]. Companies providing tourist accommodation services and campsite services are also invited to consult the relevant provisions of the EU Ecolabel [http://ec.europa.eu/environment/ecolabel/products-groups-and-criteria.html]. Destination managers may also refer to other EU initiatives promoting sustainable tourism management, such as, among others, the European Tourism Indicators System (ETIS) [ETIS is a management and information toolkit, designed for helping destination in monitoring and measuring their sustainable tourism performances, against their own target. Further information is available at: http://ec.europa.eu/growth/sectors/tourism/offer/sustainable/indicators/index_en.htm].

The actors mentioned above are interlinked with a variety of other sectors as portrayed in the tourism value chain diagram below. In terms of tourism as a product, the activities that a tourist participates in whilst on holiday are also an important part of the tourism value chain, and are of potential environmental interest. However, they are only referred to in this SRD insofar as they may be influenced by destination managers and tour operators.

The main environmental aspects and associated environmental pressures arising from tourism services are presented in the table below. These environmental aspects were selected as the most relevant in the sector. However, the environmental aspects to be managed by specific organisations should be assessed on a case by case basis.

[CFC and HCFC stand for chlorofluorocarbon and hydrochlorofluorocarbon.]

Service/Activity | Main environmental aspects | Main environmental pressures

Administration |

Office management

Reception of clients

Energy, water and material (mainly paper) consumption

Generation of municipal waste (large amounts of paper) and hazardous waste (e.g. toner cartridges)

Technical services |

Production of hot water and space heating/cooling

Lighting

Elevators

Swimming pools

Green areas

Pest and rodent control

Repair and maintenance

Energy and water consumption

Consumption of a range of hazardous products

In some cases use of CFC and HCFC refrigerants.

Emissions to air (air pollutants, greenhouse gases)

Generation of a wide range of potentially hazardous waste types such as empty chemical containers

Generation of waste water

Restaurant/bar |

Breakfast, dinner, lunch

Beverages and snacks

Supply chain pressures (see 'Purchasing')

Energy, water and raw material consumption

Generation of municipal waste (especially food waste and packaging waste)

Kitchen |

Food conservation

Food preparation

Dish washing

Supply chain pressures (see 'Purchasing')

Significant consumption of energy and water

Generation of municipal waste (especially food waste and packaging waste)

Generation of vegetable oil waste

Generation of odours

Room use |

Use by guests

Products for guests' use

Housekeeping

Energy, water and raw materials consumption

Use of a wide range of hazardous products

Generation of waste packaging and small amounts of municipal waste

Generation of waste water

Laundry |

Washing and ironing of guests' clothes

Washing and ironing of towel, bedclothes, etc.

Significant consumption of energy and water

Use of hazardous products

Generation of waste water

Purchasing |

Selection of products and suppliers

Storage of products

Supply chain pressures (land occupation, degradation or destruction of ecosystems, disturbance of wildlife, energy and water consumption, emissions to air — air pollutants and greenhouse gases —, emissions to water, waste generation)

Generation of packaging waste

Hazardous substance leakages

Activities |

Indoor activities

Outdoor activities

Energy, water and raw materials consumption

Local impacts on ecosystems

Noise

Generation of municipal waste

Infrastructure pressures (see 'Building and construction')

Transport |

Transport of guests

Transport of employees

Transport by suppliers

Energy (fuel) consumption

Emissions to air

Infrastructure pressures (see 'Building and construction')

Additional services |

Medical services, supermarkets, souvenir shops, spa and wellness, hairdresser, etc.

Energy, water and raw materials consumption

Generation of municipal waste, and some specific hazardous waste types (e.g. sanitary waste)

Building and construction |

Construction of new areas or services

Repair of existing areas or services

Land occupation

Degradation or destruction of ecosystems

Disturbance of wildlife

Energy and water consumption

Significant consumption of raw materials and hazardous products

Significant generation of construction waste

Generation of hazardous waste

The Best Environmental Management Practices (BEMPs) presented in this SRD are grouped as follows:

BEMPs to improve cross-cutting issues in the tourism sector,

BEMPs to improve destination management [Destination management is the coordination of all relevant government and private actors, usually by a public body with or without private participation, aimed at supporting tourism development in a destination by making strategic decisions, implementing policy actions, maintaining and promoting cultural and natural heritage and attractions, coordinating events/festivals, raising revenue for tourism-related projects, facilitating cooperation between businesses, ensuring infrastructure and service provisions…],

BEMPs to improve tour operators' and travel agents' activities,

BEMPs to minimise water consumption in accommodation facilities,

BEMPs to minimise waste production from accommodation facilities,

BEMPs to minimise energy consumption in accommodation facilities,

BEMPs to improve restaurant and hotel kitchens,

BEMPs to improve campsites.

The BEMPs cover the most significant environmental aspects of the sector.

BEMP is to undertake an assessment of the most important direct and indirect environmental aspects associated with the organisation, and to apply relevant performance indicators and compare with relevant benchmarks of excellence.

This BEMP is applicable to all tourism actors, including destination managers, tour operators, accommodation providers, food and drink providers, transport operators and activity providers. This BEMP is also fully applicable to small enterprises [A small enterprise is defined as an enterprise which employs fewer than 50 persons and whose annual turnover and/or annual balance sheet total does not exceed EUR 10 million (Commission Recommendation 2003/361/EC).].

Environmental performance indicator | Benchmarks of excellence

(i1) Implementation of an environmental management system (y/n)

(b1) Appropriate indicators are used to continuously monitor all relevant aspects of environmental performance, including less easily measurable and indirect aspects such as biodiversity impacts.

(b2) All staff are provided with information on environmental objectives and training on relevant environmental management actions.

(b3) Best environmental management practices are implemented where applicable.

BEMP is to screen supply chains for products and services used by the organisation in order to identify supply chain environmental hotspots, considering the entire value chain, and to identify relevant control points (e.g. product selection, avoidance, green procurement, supplier criteria) that can be used to minimise the environmental impact over the whole value chain.

This BEMP is applicable to all tourism actors, including destination managers, tour operators, accommodation providers, food and drink providers, transport operators and activity providers. This BEMP is also fully applicable to small enterprises.

[As part of the ISO 14000 series of environmental standards, the International Standards Organisation has drawn up a subseries (ISO 14020) specific to environmental labelling, which covers three types of labelling schemes. In this context a ‘Type I’ ecolabel is a multi-criteria label developed by a third party. Examples are, at EU level, the ‘EU Ecolabel’ or, at national or multilateral level, the ‘Blaue Engel’, the ‘Austrian Ecolabel’ and the ‘Nordic Swan’.]

Environmental performance indicator | Benchmarks of excellence

(i2) Percentage of products and services complying with specific environmental criteria (%)

(b4) The organisation has applied life cycle thinking to identify improvement options for all major supply chains that address environmental hotspots.

(b5) ≥ 97 % of chemicals (by active ingredient weight or purchased volume) used in accommodation and restaurant premises are certified according to an ISO Type I ecolabel (or can be demonstrated to be the most environmentally friendly available option).

(b6) ≥ 97 % of all wood, paper and cardboard purchased by accommodations and restaurants are recycled or environmentally certified (ecolabelled, FSC, PEFC).

BEMP is to establish a unit or organisation responsible for the strategic sustainable development of the destination that coordinates relevant departments and stakeholders to implement specific actions within the framework of a destination plan.

This BEMP is applicable to all destinations, either by units within government structures responsible for destination management or public/private destination management organisations. This BEMP is also applicable to small public administrations and small enterprises involved with destination management.

Environmental performance indicators | Benchmark of excellence

(i3) Implementation of a sustainable destination plan (y/n)

(b7) Implementation of a destination plan that: (i) covers the entire destination area; (ii) involves coordination across all relevant government and private actors; (iii) addresses key environmental challenges within the destination.

BEMP is to monitor the state of biodiversity within the destination, and to implement a biodiversity conservation and management plan that protects and enhances total biodiversity within the destination through, for example, development restrictions and compensation measures.

This BEMP is applicable to all destinations. High nature value destinations should conserve biodiversity while low nature value destinations should take measures to increase biodiversity. This BEMP is also applicable to small enterprises involved with destination management.

Environmental performance indicators | Benchmark of excellence

(i4) Implementation of a biodiversity management plan (y/n)

(i5) Species abundance in the destination area

(i6) Protected area (hectares or percentage of destination total area)

(b8) Minimise and compensate for any biodiversity displaced by tourism development so that destination-level biodiversity is maintained or increased in high nature value areas, and increased in degraded areas.

BEMP is to ensure that environment-related services within the destination, in particular water supply, waste water treatment, waste management (especially recycling measures) and public transport/traffic management, are sufficient to cope with peak demand during tourism high season in a sustainable manner.

This BEMP is applicable to all destinations. It relates to good management by public administrations in general, but is particularly relevant where tourism generates large additional and seasonal demands for services. This BEMP is also applicable to small local public administrations and to small enterprises involved with destination management or providing the environment-related services required at a destination.

Environmental performance indicators | Benchmarks of excellence

(i7) Daily water consumption per guest (l/guest-day)

This article is long: the rest is at the official publication.