[…]
Source: TESLA4, page 12
Source: Notification, Table 5, based on KPMG
(per cent)
Approach | Range of returns (project IRR; post-tax nominal) | Comments
Relative risk analysis |
8,5-11
(project basis)
Comparison of offshore wind and PPP/PFI returns during construction phase and also UK regulated utilities/nuclear operators during operations phase
Benchmarking Analysis |
6-13
(project basis)
Comparison of UK regulated utility/PPP/IWPP/comparable nuclear projects
Project Hurdle Rate analysis | 10,5-14,5 | Based on EdF WACC estimates plus premium observed in academic studies from a range of corporates
Financing analysis |
9-13 — construction
6-9,5 — operational
Analysis of potential financing structures both during construction and during operations
Assumed debt-financed structure with UK Guarantee |
10,2 — Project IRR
12,8 — Levered Equity IRR
Analysis of the Project Return and the Levered Equity Return (for the proposed UK guaranteed debt levels) and at the negotiated SP.
The 10,2 % is due to the tax shield effect on project level cash flows and indicative IUK Guarantee pricing.
[…]
Shaded cells denote construction cost capex — target IRR scenarios yielding a lower SP than 92,50 GBP/MWh. Based on NNBG Financial Model version 9.8.
[…]
Includes construction gain share benefit of GBP 0,8/MWh (real 2012)
Lump sum from SZC only released post COD2 and therefore does not form part of funding requirement
Opex adjustment only applied for first 15 yrs and after CFD period due to potential opex reopener protection.
Min DSCR excluding first period
EIRR committed real approximated as EIRR committed nominal minus long term CPI assumption
Lower level of Committed equity assumed in this version of the Financial Model will mean Committed Equity IRR is optimistic v current modelled results
VERY LOW | Very low likelihood of more favourable outcome than assumed
LOW | Low likelihood of more favourable outcome than assumed
MODERATE | Moderate likelihood of more favourable outcome than assumed
HIGH | High likelihood of more favourable outcome than assumed
VERY HIGH | Very high likelihood of more favourable outcome than assumed
[…]
[…]
Run | Key Assumptions | Capacity Market | First Nuclear Deployment | Grid carbon intensity 2030 | Grid carbon intensity 2040 | Grid carbon intensity 2049
1a | BAU | No | 2037 | 232 | 188 | 96
1d | BAU, High Fuel Prices | No | 2031 | 186 | 101 | 46
1e | BAU, Low Fuel Prices | No | 2041 | 269 | 233 | 121
2a | BAU + Nuclear CfD | No | 2023 | 158 | 88 | 37
3a | Non-nuclear Low Carbon CfDs | No | 2037 | 164 | 135 | 61
3d | Non-nuclear Low Carbon CfDs, High Fuel Prices | No | 2031 | 181 | 123 | 52
3e | Non-nuclear Low Carbon CfDs, Low Fuel Prices | No | 2041 | 182 | 120 | 66
3h | Non-nuclear Low Carbon CfDs, more interconnection | No | 2037 | 160 | 133 | 59
4a | Low Carbon CfDs | No | 2023 | 100 | 42 | 25
5a | BAU | Yes | 2037 | 236 | 194 | 88
5d | BAU, High Fuel Prices | Yes | 2032 | 194 | 111 | 52
5e | BAU, Low Fuel Prices | Yes | 2041 | 272 | 235 | 126
7a | Non-nuclear Low Carbon CfDs | Yes | 2046 | 104 | 49 | 33
7d | Non-nuclear Low Carbon CfDs, High Fuel Prices | Yes | 2038 | 137 | 65 | 28
7e | Non-nuclear Low Carbon CfDs, Low Fuel Prices | Yes | Not before 2049 | 113 | 51 | 44
7f | Non-nuclear Low Carbon CfDs, High Nuclear Costs, Low RES and CCS costs | Yes | 2048 | 97 | 46 | 35
7g (only to 2030) | Non-nuclear Low Carbon CfDs, more DSR, more EDR, more Interconnection | Yes | Not before 2030 | 104 | N/A | N/A
7h | Non-nuclear Low Carbon CfDs, more interconnection | Yes | 2046 | 101 | 48 | 32
8a | Low Carbon CfDs | Yes | 2023 | 104 | 50 | 31
8d | Low Carbon CfDs, High Fuel Prices | Yes | 2023 | 99 | 48 | 30
8e | Low Carbon CfDs, Low Fuel Prices | Yes | 2023 | 99 | 38 | 30
8f | Low Carbon CfDs, High Nuclear costs, Low RES and CCS costs | Yes | 2023 | 102 | 45 | 28
8g (only to 2030) | Low Carbon CfDs, more DSR, more EDR, more Interconnection | Yes | 2023 | 98 | N/A | N/A
8h | Low Carbon CfDs, more Interconnection | Yes | 2023 | 100 | 53 | 32
Source: UK submission ‘Answers to the Commission's questions received 16 September 2014’ based on Fund websites, Preqin, Press releases. Note: Fund target IRRs shown gross of fees and expenses. Exchange rates used: GBP EUR: 1: 1,26, GBP CAD: 1: 1,81. HPC post-tax nominal equity IRR used for comparison purposes. Borealis target IRR: 9 – 12 per cent, First State EDIF target IRR: 10 – 15 per cent.
Sponsor | Antin Infrastructure Partners | CDP Capital | Brookfield Renewable Energy Partners |
Borealis,
First State EDIF
Fund Target
Equity IRR
15 % | 16 % | 9 – 12 % | 9 – 15 %
[Final Proposals for National Grid Electricity Distribution and National Grid Gas] [Ofwat Future water and sewerage charges 2010-2015: Final determinations] [Ofwat: Setting price controls for 2015-20 — risk and reward guidance]
Source: Presentation of EDF Energy to Commission officials of 15 July 2014, slide ‘Comparison of HPC with UK regulated utilities’.
Electricity Transmission (Ofgem) | Ofwat — PR09 | Ofwat — PR 14 (not finalised)
Note | | |
Period | 2013-21 | 2010-15 | 2015-20
Real
Levered cost of equity (post-tax) | 7,00 per cent | 7,10 per cent | 5,65 per cent
Cost of debt (pre-tax real) | 2,92 per cent | 3,60 per cent | 2,75 per cent
Notional gearing | 60,0 per cent | 57,5 per cent | 62,5 per cent
Vanilla WACC | 4,55 per cent | 5,10 per cent | 3,85 per cent
Inflation assumption | 3,50 per cent | 3,50 per cent | 3,50 per cent
Allowed Nominal Costs/Returns (geometric calc)
Levered cost of equity | 10,7 per cent | 10,8 per cent | 9,3 per cent
Cost of debt (pre-tax) | 6,5 per cent | 7,2 per cent | 6,3 per cent
Vanilla WACC* | 8,2 per cent | 8,8 per cent | 7,5 per cent
Nominal (arithmetic calc)
Levered cost of equity* | 10,5 per cent | 10,6 per cent | 9,2 per cent
Cost of debt (pre-tax)* | 6,4 per cent | 7,1 per cent | 6,3 per cent
Vanilla WACC | 8,1 per cent | 8,6 per cent | 7,3 per cent
https://www.ofgem.gov.uk/ofgem-publications/53602/4riiot1fpfinancedec12.pdf
http://www.ofwat.gov.uk/pricereview/pr14/gud_tec20140127riskreward.pdf
http://www.ofwat.gov.uk/pricereview/pr09phase3/det_pr09_finalfull.pdf
Source: UK submission ‘Answers to the Commission's questions received 16 September 2014’ based on publicly available documents (Bruce Power audit report — April 2007, p. 14.: Confirmed as a project rate of return in letter from CIBC World Markets Inc. to The Ministry of Energy, Ontario, 17 October 2005, http://www.rds.ontarioenergyboard.ca/webdrawer/webdrawer.dll/webdrawer/rec/67137/view/PWU_Exhibit_K11.3_fairness_opinion_bruce_20080613.pdf.PDF, Letter from CIBC World Markets Inc. to the Ministry of Energy, Ontario, 17 October 2005, http://www.rds.ontarioenergyboard.ca/webdrawer/webdrawer.dll/webdrawer/rec/67137/view/PWU_Exhibit_K11.3_fairness_opinion_bruce_20080613.pdf.PDF Bruce Power Fairness Opinion (CIBC World Markets Inc.) — October 2005, p. 5.
Project | Ontario Power Authority
Technology | Refurbishment of Bruce Power nuclear plant
Gearing | 20-40 per cent
Real cost of debt (pre-tax) | 6,20 per cent
Nominal target equity IRR (post-tax) | 13,7-18 per cent (12,8-17,1 per cent adjusted for current UK interest rate)
Target project IRR | 10,6-13,8 per cent (9,7-12,9 per cent adjusted for current UK interest rate)
Investment horizon (asset life) | 25 years
Investment size | 4bn CAD
Level of Revenue certainty | Fixed price CfD for remainder of plant life (25 years)
Level of construction risk | Lower — refurbishment, not new build, cost overrun sharing
Level of operating risk | Lower — staff cost overrun sharing, fuel cost pass-through
Level of financing risk | Lower — smaller capital project, shorter period
Contingent equity required | Unknown
Source: UK submission, Table 2 — on Rate of Return, 10th September as well as (1) and (2) below.
[In tenders for Independent Water and Power Producer (IWPP) contracts in Abu Dhabi, which include a 20 year fixed-price water/power purchase agreement with inflation indexation, ‘the nominal internal rate of return (IRR) on equity is required to be not less than 13 per cent’. These projects will typically involve construction of technically — mature CCGT capacity under a lump sum, date-certain turnkey EPC contract, with provisions to compensate investors for any delays and deviations from the terms of the contract. See Independent water and power producers, Abu Dhabi Regulation & Supervision Bureau, http://rsb.gov.ae/assets/documents/231/infoiwpp.pdf. (Source: UK submission)] [http://www.gdfsuez.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/GDF-SUEZ-at-a-glance-060712-final.pdf Slide 8] [While the UK's submission quotes 9-15 per cent post-tax nominal rates of returns from the source given in (2), the Commission notes that this seems to ignore the ‘regulated and concession’ projects mentioned in that source. The Commission understands from (2) that the regulated and concession activities of GDF-Suez are indicated to realise around 5-13 per cent post-tax nominal project returns, with the most likely range being below 10 per cent.]
Technology | CCGT | PPA projects
Gearing | < 80 per cent | Unknown
Cost of debt | Unknown | Unknown
Nominal target return on equity (post-tax) | > 13 per cent |
Nominal target project return (post-tax) | | 9-15 per cent
Investment horizon (asset life) | 25 years | Various
Investment size | Various | Various
Degree of revenue certainty | 20 year PPA | PPA
Level of construction risk compared to HPC | Lower-EPC contract-based, well-known technology | Unknown but likely lower
Level of operating risk compared to HPC | Lower | Unknown
Level of financing risk | Lower shorter construction period | Unknown but likely lower
Contingent equity required | Unknown | Unknown
References | |
[http://www.ofwat.gov.uk/pricereview/pr14/gud_tec20140127riskreward.pdf] [https://www.ofgem.gov.uk/ofgem-publications/86375/fast-trackdecisionletter.pdf] [https://assets.digital.cabinet-office.gov.uk/media/535a5768ed915d0fdb000003/NIE_Final_determination.pdf. The Commission notes that while Table 13.10 of the quoted document provides a ‘low’ and a ‘high’ estimate for the reported financial indicators, the UK's submission seems to be based on the ‘high’ estimates alone.] [https://www.ofgem.gov.uk/publications-and-updates/riio-t1-final-proposals-national-grid-electricity-transmission-and-national-grid-gas-–-overview] [Source was not provided in the submission.] [http://www.caa.co.uk/docs/33/CAP%201140.pdf] [http://orr.gov.uk/data/assets/pdf_file/0011/452/pr13-final-determination.pdf] [Nominal values are calculated using an arithmetic approach. A geometric approach would add 0,1 per cent-0,2 per cent to nominal cost of equity and nominal vanilla WACC estimates.] [Credit Suisse: National Grid — No longer a growth/value play, cut to Neutral, 29 May 2014; Credit Suisse: SSE — Referendum risk to be addressed, 15 August 2014; Macquarie: National Grid — Quality costs, but better opportunities elsewhere, 24 March 2014.] [The submission interpreted the length of the investment horizon as the length of a price control period. However, the submission notes that the asset lives of the investments undertaken by regulated companies often span multiple price control periods, having ‘useful lives’ of up to 60 years.] [The value ascribed by the regulator to the capital employed in the licensee's business.] [Where source RAV values are stated in historical price terms, they have been converted to current prices using the ONS RPI index (unless otherwise stated).] [We note that regulated companies' investment expenditure is in diverse, multiple projects that typically form only a small proportion of its RAV.] [http://ofwat.gov.uk/regulating/prs_web_rcvupdates] [http://www.westernpower.co.uk/docs/About-us/financial-information/2014/Annual-reports-and-financial-statements/Financial-performance-for-website-Mar-14.aspx] [http://www.uregni.gov.uk/uploads/publications/RP5_Main_Paper_22-10-12_FINAL.pdf (page 100).] [This is Ofgem's forecast for RAV at the end of the price control period. Note that at the start of the price control period SHETL is estimated to have a RAV of 0,7bn (which is forecast to increase to 3,6 bn by 2020-21): https://www.ofgem.gov.uk/ofgem-publications/53747/sptshetlfpsupport.pdf (pages 36 and 37) and https://www.ofgem.gov.uk/ofgem-publications/53602/4riiot1fpfinancedec12.pdf (pages 8 and 9).] [http://www.bristolwater.co.uk/wp/wp-content/uploads/2013/04/Annual-Report-2013.pdf (page 27).] [http://www.heathrowairport.com/static/HeathrowAboutUs/Downloads/PDF/Development_of_Regulatory_Asset_Base_30-Jun-2014.pdf] [http://www.networkrail.co.uk/browse%20documents/regulatory%20documents/regulatory%20compliance%20and%20reporting/regulatory%20accounts/nril%20regulatory%20financial%20statements%20for%20the%20year%20ended%2031%20march%202013.pdf (page 331).]
Source: based on UK submission ‘SA.34974 Hinkley Point C State aid case — Answers to the Commission's questions received 16 September 2014’.
Regulator | Ofwat | Ofgem | CC | Ofgem | CC | CAA | ORR
Determination | PR14 (not final) | WPD 14 | NIE 2014 Final | RIIO T1 2012 (NGET) | Bristol W 2010 | HAL 2014 Final | NR 2013
Gearing | 62,50 per cent | 65 per cent | 45 per cent | 60 per cent | 60 per cent | 60 per cent | 62,50 per cent
Real cost of debt (pre-tax) | 2,8 per cent | 2,6 per cent | 3,1 per cent | 2,9 per cent | 3,9 per cent | 3,2 per cent | 3,0 per cent
Real cost of equity (post-tax) | 5,7 per cent | 6,4 per cent | 5,0 per cent | 7,0 per cent | 6,6 per cent | 6,8 per cent | 6,5 per cent
Real vanilla WACC | 3,8 per cent | 3,9 per cent | 4,1 per cent | 4,6 per cent | 5,0 per cent | 4,7 per cent | 4,3 per cent
Inflation | 3,5 per cent | 3,5 per cent | 3,5 per cent | 3,5 per cent | 3,5 per cent | 3,5 per cent | 3,5 per cent
Nominal cost of debt (pre-tax) | 6,2 per cent | 6,1 per cent | 6,6 per cent | 6,4 per cent | 7,4 per cent | 6,7 per cent | 6,5 per cent
Nominal cost of equity (post- tax) | 9,2 per cent | 9,9 per cent | 8,5 per cent | 10,5 per cent | 10,1 per cent | 10,3 per cent | 10,0 per cent
Nominal vanilla WACC | 7,3 per cent | 7,4 per cent | 7,6 per cent | 8,1 per cent | 8,5 per cent | 8,2 per cent | 7,8 per cent
Analyst return on equity forecast (ex ante) | | | | c 14 per cent | | |
Investment horizon — Price control length | 5 | 8 | 3 | 8 | 5 | 5 | 5
Investment Size: Regulatory Asset Value (RAV) | 70m — 11,7bn (estimated 2014 — 15) values) | 5,9bn (2014) | c GBP 950m (forecast across price control) | 2,2bn — 14,8bn (forecast RAV range of companies over price control) | 0,39bn (2013) | 14,9bn | 45bn (2013)
Degree of revenue protection | More than HPC — see answer to question 2c — NNBG Submission on Rate of Return, 10 September
Degree of construction risk | Less than HPC. See detailed discussion recitals 124 – 131 — NNBG Submission on Rate of Return, 10 September
Degree of operating risk | Less than HPC. See detailed discussion recitals 132 – 135 — NNBG Submission on Rate of Return, 10 September
Degree of financing risk | Less than HPC. See detailed discussion paragraphs 136 – 139 — NNBG Submission on Rate of Return, 10 September
Other risks | Less than HPC. See detailed discussion on difference in fundamental business models; diversification of assets; and technology risks in recitals 113 – 122 — NNBG Submission on Rate of Return, 10 September
Contingent equity required | None
Source: http://www.stern.nyu.edu/~adamodar/pc/datasets/Eurocompfirm.xls (retrieved on 14 June 2014).
(The presented WACCs are nominal (in USD terms, using USD risk free rate = 3,04 per cent) & post-tax. For the various definitions used by Damodaran, see: http://pages.stern.nyu.edu/~adamodar/New_Home_Page/datafile/variable.htm).
(per cent)
Company Name | Country | Cost of equity in USD | Pre-tax cost of debt in USD | After-tax cost of debt in USD | Cost of capital in USD
E.ON SE (DB:EOAN) | Germany | 8,25 | 4,04 | 3,19 | 5,78
RWE AG (DB:RWE) | Germany | 7,95 | 4,54 | 3,59 | 5,54
Centrica plc (LSE:CNA) | UK | 6,99 | 4,44 | 3,11 | 6,04
Veolia Environnement S.A. (ENXTPA:VIE) | France | 11,62 | 5,44 | 4,30 | 6,46
National Grid plc (LSE:NG.) | UK | 9,37 | 4,44 | 3,11 | 6,33
Suez Environnement Company SA (ENXTPA:SEV) | France | 9,97 | 4,94 | 3,90 | 6,38
A2A SpA. (BIT:A2A) | Italy | 13,72 | 7,44 | 5,88 | 8,68
Hera SpA. (BIT:HER) | Italy | 12,65 | 5,94 | 4,69 | 7,94
MVV Energie AG (XTRA:MVV1) | Germany | 8,31 | 4,04 | 3,19 | 5,70
ACEA SpA. (BIT:ACE) | Italy | 12,15 | 6,44 | 5,09 | 7,68
Iren SpA (BIT:IRE) | Italy | 13,85 | 7,94 | 6,27 | 8,80
Mainova AG (DB:MNV6) | Germany | 6,96 | 5,54 | 4,38 | 6,30
Gelsenwasser AG (DB:WWG) | Germany | 6,09 | 5,54 | 4,38 | 6,08
Telecom Plus plc (LSE:TEP) | UK | 6,45 | 4,94 | 3,46 | 6,44
Compagnie Parisienne de Chauffage Urbain (ENXTPA:CHAU) | France | 7,73 | 4,94 | 3,90 | 6,33
Zespól Elektrocieplowni Wroclawskich KOGENERACJA Spólka Akcyjna (WSE:KGN) | Poland | 7,44 | 5,39 | 4,26 | 6,94
Fintel Energia Group SpA (BIT:FTL) | Italy | 9,88 | 8,94 | 7,06 | 9,02
REN — Redes Energéticas Nacionais, SGPS, S.A. (ENXTLS:RENE) | Portugal | 19,97 | 7,64 | 6,04 | 10,05
GDF SUEZ S.A. (ENXTPA:GSZ) | France | 8,70 | 4,44 | 3,51 | 5,74
Burgenland Holding Aktiengesellschaft (WBAG:BHD) | Austria | 6,08 | 5,54 | 4,38 | 6,08