1 ANNEX, 2012/148/EU: Commission Recommendation of 9 March 2012 on preparations for the roll-out…

In forcesince 9 Mar 2012

1.1. European Commission — Joint Research Centre Institute for Energy and Transport (2012). ‘Guidelines for conducting a cost-benefit analysis of smart grid projects’, available at: http://ses.jrc.ec.europa.eu/

1.2. European Commission — Joint Research Centre Institute for Energy and Transport (2012). ‘Guidelines for cost-benefit analysis of smart metering deployment’, available at: http://ses.jrc.ec.europa.eu/

1.3. European Regulators’ Group for Electricity and Gas. ‘Final Guidelines of Good Practice on Regulatory Aspects of Smart Metering for Electricity and Gas’, February 2011, Ref.: E10-RMF-29-05 http://www.smartgridscre.fr/media/documents/ERGEG_Guidelines_of_good_practice.pdf

1.4. European Commission Task Force for Smart Grids (2010), Expert Group 3: Roles and responsibilities of actors involved in smart grids deployment, ‘Merit deployment matrix’ available at: http://ec.europa.eu/energy/gas_electricity/smartgrids/doc/expert_group3_annex.xls

1.5. Proposal for a Directive on energy efficiency and repealing Directives 2004/8/EC and 2006/32/EC [COM(2011) 370 final, 22 June 2011]

1.6. SEC(2011) 288 final — Commission Staff Working Document ‘Impact Assessment’ accompanying the Communication from the Commission to the European Parliament, the Council, the European Economic and Social Committee and the Committee of the Regions, ‘A roadmap for moving to a competitive low-carbon economy in 2050’ (COM(2011) 112 final) (SEC(2011) 289 final)

Variables/data to be set/collected | Unit

Projected variation of energy consumption | %

Projected variation of energy prices | %

Peak load transfer | %

Electricity losses at transmission and distribution level | %

Estimated non-supplied minutes | Number of minutes

Value of lost load; value of supply | EUR/kWh

Discount rate | %

Hardware costs (e.g. smart meter, GPRS/PLC modem, etc.) | EUR

Number of smart metering systems to be installed | Number of smart meters

Installation costs for smart metering system | EUR

Life expectancy of smart metering system | Number of years

Meter reading costs | EUR/year

Telecommunication success rate | %

Inflation rate | %

Cost reduction associated with technology maturity | %

Implementation schedule | Number of smart meters/year

Percentage of meters placed in rural v urban areas | %

Carbon costs | EUR/tonne

In cases where the analysis permits the calculation of costs and benefits of resulting changes to carbon emissions, it is recommended that the analysis considers the carbon prices projected both in the Commission reference and decarbonisation scenarios [Annex 7.10 to Commission Staff Working Document SEC(2011) 288 final — ‘Impact Assessment’: http://eur-lex.europa.eu/LexUriServ/LexUriServ.do?uri=SEC:2011:0288:FIN:EN:PDF].

General category | Type of cost to be tracked for roll-out and to be estimated for the baseline

CAPEX | Investment in the smart metering systems

Investment in IT

Investment in communications

Investment in in-home displays (if applicable)

Generation

Transmission

Distribution

Avoided investment in conventional meters (negative cost, to be added to the list of benefits)

OPEX | IT maintenance costs

Network management and front-end costs

Communication/data transfer costs (inc. GPRS, radio communications, etc.)

Scenario management costs

Replacement/failure of smart metering systems (incremental)

Revenue reductions (e.g. through more efficient consumption)

Generation

Distribution

Transmission

Meter reading

Call centre/customer care

Training costs (e.g. customer care personnel and installation personnel)

Reliability | Restoration costs

Environmental | Emission costs (CO2 control equipment, operation and emission permits)

Energy security | Cost of fossil fuels consumed to generate power

Cost of fossil fuels for transportation and operation

Other | Cost of consumer engagement programmes

Sunk costs of previously installed (traditional) meters

[Low voltage.] [Medium voltage.]

Benefit | Sub-benefit | Monetisation calculation

Reduction in meter reading and operations costs | Reduced meter operations costs | Value (EUR) = [Estimated cost reductions with remote meter operations (EUR/year)] Roll-out – [Estimated cost reductions with remote meter operations (EUR/year) × Communications failure rate (%/100)]Roll-out scenario

Reduced meter reading costs |

Value (EUR) = [cost with local meter readings (EUR)]Baseline – [Estimated cost of obtaining local ‘disperse’ meter readings (EUR)]Roll-out scenario

Where:

[cost with local meter readings (EUR)]Baselinenumber of clients in LV × Historical meter reading cost/client/year (EUR)

[Estimated cost of obtaining local ‘disperse’ meter readings (EUR)]Roll-out scenario[number of clients in LV × % of clients not included in the roll-out × Average disperse reading cost per client (EUR/client)] + [number of clients in LV × % of clients included in the roll-out × Communications failure rate (%) × Average disperse reading cost per client (EUR/number of clients)

Reduced billing costs | Value (EUR) = [number of clients in LV × Billing cost/client/year (EUR)]Baseline – [number of clients in LV × Billing cost/client/year (EUR)]Roll-out scenario

Reduced call centre/customer care costs | Value (EUR) = [number of clients in LV × Customer care cost/client/year (EUR)]Baseline – [number of clients in LV × Customer care cost/client/year (EUR)]Roll-out scenario

Reduction in operational and maintenance costs | Reduced maintenance costs of assets | Value (EUR) = [Direct costs relating to maintenance of assets(EUR/year)]Baseline – [Direct costs relating to maintenance of assets (EUR/year)]Roll-out scenario

Reduced costs of equipment breakdowns | Value (EUR) = [Cost of equipment breakdowns (EUR/year)]Baseline – [Cost of equipment breakdowns (EUR/year)]Roll-out scenario

Deferred/avoided distribution capacity investments | Deferred distribution capacity investments due to asset remuneration | Value (EUR) = Annual investment to support growing capacity (EUR/year) × Time deferred (number of years) × Remuneration rate on investment (%/100)

Deferred distribution capacity investments due to asset amortisation | Value (EUR) = Annual investment to support growing capacity (EUR/year) × Time deferred (number of years) × number of years capacity asset amortisation

Deferred/avoided transmission capacity investments | Deferred transmission capacity investments due to asset remuneration | Value (EUR) = Annual investment to support growing capacity (EUR/year) × Time deferred (number of years) × Remuneration rate on investment (%/100)

Deferred transmission capacity investments due to asset amortisation | Value (EUR) = Annual investment to support growing capacity (EUR/year) × Time deferred (number of years) × number of years capacity asset amortisation

Deferred/avoided generation capacity investments | Deferred generation investments for peak load plants | Value (EUR) = Annual investment to support peak load generation (EUR/year) × Time deferred (number of years)

Deferred generation investments for spinning reserves | Value (EUR) = Annual investment to support spinning reserve generation (EUR/year) × Time deferred (number of years)

Reduction of technical losses of electricity | Reduced technical losses of electricity | Value (EUR) = Reduced losses via energy efficiency (EUR/year) + Reduced losses via voltage control (EUR/year) + Reduced losses at transmission level (EUR/year)

Electricity cost savings | Consumption reduction | Value (EUR) = Energy rate (EUR/MWh) × Total energy consumption at LV (MWh) × Estimated % of consumption reduction with roll-out (%/100)

Peak load transfer | Value (EUR) = Wholesale margin difference between peak and non-peak generation margin (EUR/MWh) × % Peak load transfer (%/100) × Total energy consumption at LV (MWh)

Reduction of commercial losses | Reduced electricity theft | Value (EUR) = % of clients with energy theft (%/100) × Estimated average price value of energy load not recorded/client/year (EUR) × Total number of clients LV (number of clients)

Recovered revenue relating to ‘contracted power’ fraud | Value (EUR) = % of clients with ‘contracted power fraud’ (%/100) × Estimated price value of contracted power not paid/client/year (EUR) × Total number of clients LV (number of clients)

Recovered revenue relating to incremental ‘contracted power’ | Value (EUR) = % of clients requesting incremental contracted power after smart metering system installation (%/100) × Average estimated value of recovered revenue due to incremental contracted power (EUR) × Total number of clients LV (number of clients)

Reduction of outage times (thanks to advanced monitoring and real-time network information) | Value of service | Value (EUR) = Total energy consumed MV + LV (MWh)/minutes per year (number/year) × Average non-supplied minutes/year (number/year) × Value of lost load (EUR/MWh) × % Decrease in outage time (%/100)

Reduced cost of client indemnification | Value (EUR) = Average annual client indemnifications (EUR) × % Reduction of client compensations

Reduction of CO2 emissions | Reduced CO2 emissions due to reduced line losses |

Value (EUR) = [Line losses (MWh) × CO2 content (tonnes/MWh) × Value of CO2 (EUR/tonne)]Baseline –

[Line losses (MWh) × CO2 content (tonnes/MWh) × Value of CO2 (EUR/tonne)]Roll-out scenario

Reduced CO2 emissions due to wider spread of low-carbon generation sources (as a consequence of the roll-out of smart metering) | Value (EUR) = [CO2 emissions (tonnes) × Value of CO2 (EUR/tonne)] Baseline – [CO2 emissions (tonnes) × Value of CO2 (EUR/tonne)]Roll-out scenario

Reduced CO2 emissions due to truck rolls of field personnel | Value (EUR) = Avoided number litres of fuel (number) × Cost per litre of fuel (EUR)

Reduced fuel usage due to truck rolls of field personnel | Value (EUR) = Avoided number litres of fuel (number) × Cost per litre of fuel (EUR)

Reduction of air pollution (Particulate Matters, NOx, SO2) | Reduced air pollutants emissions due to reduced line losses |

For each pollutant:

Value (EUR) = [Line losses (MWh) × air pollutant content (unit/MWh) × cost of air pollutant (EUR/unit)] Baseline –

Line losses (MWh) × air pollutant content (unit/MWh) × cost of air pollutant (EUR/unit)]Roll-out scenario

Reduced air pollutants emissions due to wider diffusion of low carbon generation sources (as a consequence of the roll-out of smart metering) |

For each pollutant:

Value (EUR) = [air pollutant Emissions (unit) × cost of air pollutant(EUR/unit)] Baseline – [air pollutant Emissions (unit) × cost of air pollutant(EUR/unit)]Roll-out scenario

Reduced air pollutants emissions due to truck rolls of field personnel | Value (EUR) = Avoided number litre of fuel (number) × Cost per litre of fuel avoided (EUR)

Note: For the ‘cost of air pollutants’ (particulate matters, NOx, SO2), it is recommended to consult the Clean Vehicles Directive – Directive 2009/33/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 23 April 2009 on the promotion of clean and energy-efficient road transport vehicles [OJ L 120, 15.5.2009, p. 5.], and the ‘CAFÉ’ (Clean Air For Europe) air quality benefits’ quantification process.