163 7. DEFINITIVE MEASURES › 7.1. Injury elimination level, Council Implementing Regulation (EU) No 857/2010 of 27 September 2010 imposing a definit…

In force

One interested party claimed that a target profit of 5 % was overstated for the second quarter of the IP given that in this quarter (4th quarter of 2008) not only the demand was lower (winter season), but the global economic crisis also affected the PET producers heavily. Thus, it is claimed that a correct application of the principle developed in Case T-210/95 [Case T-210/95 European Fertilizer Manufacturers’ Association (EFMA) v Council of the European Union, ECR 1999, p. II-3291.] must lead to a 0 % margin in the absence of subsidised imports. Moreover, the party claimed, since all quarters of the IP were affected by the crisis, also in the other quarters, a 5 % profit margin would appear as unrealistic given that even without an economic crisis, i.e. in 2006/2007, the Union industry did not come close to the 5 % profit.

  • Judgment of the Court of First Instance (Second Chamber, extended composition) of 28 October 1999. European Fertilizer Manufacturers' AssociDecision

    28 Oct 1999 · 61995TJ0210

  • case:eu=T-2010/95