1 ANNEX, Decision_act (EU) 2009/767

In forcesince 1 Feb 2014

The purpose of the Common Template for Member States’ ‘Trusted List of supervised/accredited Certification Service Providers’ is to establish a common way in which each Member State provides information about the supervision/accreditation status of the certification services from Certification Service Providers [As defined in Article 2(11) of Directive 1999/93/EC.] (CSPs) who are supervised/accredited by them for compliance with the relevant provisions of Directive 1999/93/EC. This includes the provision of historical information about the supervision/accreditation status of the supervised/accredited certification services.

This information is primarily aimed at supporting the validation of Qualified Electronic Signatures (QES) and Advanced Electronic Signatures (AdES) [As defined in Article 2(2) of Directive 1999/93/EC.] supported by a Qualified Certificate [For an AdES supported by a QC the acronym ‘AdESQC’ is used throughout the present document.] [Note that there are a number of electronic services based on simple AdES whose cross-border use would also be facilitated, provided that the supporting certification services (e.g. issuing of non-qualified certificates) are part of the supervised/accredited services covered by a Member State in the voluntary information part of their Trusted List.].

The mandatory information in the Trusted List must include, as a minimum, information on supervised/accredited CSPs issuing Qualified Certificates (QCs) [As defined in Article 2(10) of Directive 1999/93/EC.] in accordance with the provisions laid down in Directive 1999/93/EC (Article 3(2) and (3), and Article 7(1)(a)), including, when this is not part of the QCs, information on the QCs supporting an electronic signature and whether or not the signature is created by a Secure Signature Creation Device (SSCD) [As defined in Article 2(6) of Directive 1999/93/EC.].

Additional information on other CSPs not issuing QCs but providing services related to electronic signatures (e.g. CSP providing Time Stamping Services and issuing Time Stamp Tokens, CSP issuing non-Qualified certificates, etc.) may be included in the Trusted List at a national level on a voluntary basis provided they are either accredited/supervised in a similar way as the CSPs issuing QC or approved under a different national approval scheme. The national approval schemes may in some Member States differ from the supervision or voluntary accreditation schemes applicable for CSPs issuing QCs with regard to applicable requirements and/or the responsible organisation. The terms ‘accredited’ and/or ‘supervised’ in the present specifications also cover the national approval schemes but additional information on the nature of any national schemes will be provided by Member States in their Trusted List, including clarification on the possible differences with the accreditation/supervision schemes applied to CSPs issuing QCs.

The Common Template relies on ETSI TS 119 612 v1.1.1 [ETSI TS 119 612 v1.1.1 (2013-06) – Electronic Signatures and Infrastructures (ESI); Trusted Lists.] (hereafter referred to as ETSI TS 119 612) that addresses the establishment, publication, location, access, authentication and integrity of such lists.

The Common Template for a Member State Trusted List is structured according to ETSI TS 119 612 into the following categories of information:

1.

A trusted list tag facilitating the identification of the Trusted List during electronic searches;

2.

Information on the Trusted List and its issuing scheme;

3.

A sequence of fields containing unambiguous identification information about every supervised/accredited CSP under the scheme (this sequence is optional, i.e. when not used, the list will be deemed to have no content thereby denoting the absence of any supervised or accredited CSP in the associated Member State for the purposes of the Trusted List);

4.

For each listed CSP, the details of its specific trust services, the current status of which are recorded within the Trusted List, are provided as a sequence of fields unambiguously identifying supervised/accredited certification services provided by the CSP and their current status (this sequence must have a minimum of one entry);

5.

For each listed supervised/accredited certification service, the information on the history of this status, when applicable;

6.

The signature applied on the Trusted List.

In the context of a CSP issuing QCs, the structure of the Trusted List and in particular the service information component (as per point 4 above) allows for complementary information in service information extensions to compensate for those situations where insufficient (machine processable) information is available within the qualified certificate about its ‘qualified’ status, its potential support by an SSCD and especially in order to cope with the additional fact that most of the (commercial) CSPs are using one single issuing Certification Authority (CA) to issue several types of end-entity certificates, both qualified and non-qualified.

In the context of certificate generation (CA) services, the number of service entries in the list for a CSP may be reduced where one or several upper CA services exist within the CSP’s PKI (e.g. in the context of a hierarchy of CAs from a Root CA down to several issuing CAs) by listing such upper CA services and not the CA services issuing end-entity certificates (e.g. listing the CSP Root CA only). However in those cases, the status information applies to the whole hierarchy of CA services below the listed service and the principle of ensuring the unambiguous link between a CSPQC certification service and the set of certificates intended to be identified as QCs has to be maintained and ensured.

The following information is part of this category:

A Trusted List format version identifier,

A Trusted List sequence (or release) number,

A Trusted List type information (e.g. for identification of the fact that this Trusted List is providing information on the supervision/accreditation status of certification services from CSPs supervised/accredited by the referenced Member State for compliance with the provisions laid down in Directive 1999/93/EC),

A Trusted List scheme operator (owner) information (e.g. name, address, contact information, etc. of the Member State Body in charge of establishing, publishing securely and maintaining the Trusted List);

Information about the underlying supervision/accreditation scheme(s) to which the Trusted List is associated, including but not limited to:

the country in which it applies,

information on or reference to the location where information on the scheme(s) can be found (scheme model, rules, criteria, applicable community, type, etc.),

period of retention of (historical) information,

Trusted List policy and/or legal notice, liabilities, responsibilities,

Trusted List issue date and time,

Trusted List next planned update.

This set of information includes at least the following:

The CSP organisation name as used in formal legal registrations (including the CSP organisation UID following Member State practices),

The CSP address and contact information,

Additional information on the CSP either included directly or by reference to a location from where such additional information can be downloaded.

This set of information includes at least the following for each certification service from a listed CSP:

Service type identifier: An identifier of the type of certification service (e.g. identifier indicating that the supervised/accredited certification service from the CSP is a Certification Authority issuing QCs),

Service (trade) name: (trade) name of this certification service,

Service digital identity: An unambiguous unique identifier of the certification service,

Service current status: An identifier of the current status of the service,

The current status starting date and time,

Service information extension, when applicable: Additional information on the service (e.g. directly included or included by reference to a location from which information can be downloaded): service definition information provided by the scheme operator, access information with regards to the service, service definition information provided by the CSP and service information extensions. E.g. for CA/QC services, an optional sequence of tuples of information, each tuple providing,

Criteria to be used to further identify (filter) within the identified trust service that precise set of service outputs (e.g. set of (qualified) certificates) for which additional information is required/provided with regards to its status, the indication of the SSCD support and/or issuance to a legal person, and

The associated ‘qualifiers’ providing information on whether the set of service outputs identifies certificates to be considered as qualified and/or whether the identified qualified certificates from this service are supported by an SSCD or not, and/or information about whether such QCs are issued to legal person (by default they are to be considered as issued to natural persons).

The Trusted List of a Member State means the ‘Supervision/Accreditation Status List of certification services from Certification Service Providers who are supervised/accredited by the referenced Member State for compliance with the relevant provisions of Directive 1999/93/EC’.

Such a Trusted List is the single instrument to be used by the relevant Member State to provide information on the supervision/accreditation status of certification services and their providers:

all Certification Service Providers, as defined in Article 2(11) of Directive 1999/93/EC, i.e. ‘entity or a legal or natural person who issues certificates or provides other services related to electronic signatures’,

that are supervised/accredited for compliance with the relevant provisions laid down in Directive 1999/93/EC.

When considering the definitions and provisions laid down in Directive 1999/93/EC, in particular with regard to the relevant CSPs and their supervision/voluntary accreditation systems, two sets of CSPs can be distinguished, namely the CSPs issuing QCs to the public (CSPQC), and the CSPs not issuing QCs to the public but providing ‘other (ancillary) services related to electronic signatures’:

CSPs issuing QCs:

They must be supervised by the Member State in which they are established (if they are established in a Member State) and may also be accredited for compliance with the provisions laid down in Directive 1999/93/EC, including with the requirements of Annex I (requirements for QCs), and those of Annex II (requirements for CSPs issuing QCs). CSPs issuing QCs that are accredited in a Member State must still fall under the appropriate supervision system of that Member State unless they are not established in that Member State.

The applicable ‘supervision’ system (respectively ‘voluntary accreditation’ system) is defined and must meet the relevant requirements of Directive 1999/93/EC, in particular those laid down in Article 3(3), Article 8(1), Article 11, recital 13 (respectively, Article 2(13), Article 3(2), Article 7(1)(a), Article 8(1), Article 11, recitals 4, 11, 12 and 13).

CSPs not issuing QCs:

They may fall under a ‘voluntary accreditation’ system (as defined in and in accordance with Directive 1999/93/EC) and/or under a nationally defined ‘recognised approval scheme’ implemented on a national basis for the supervision of compliance with the provisions laid down in that Directive and possibly with national provisions with regard to the provision of certification services (in the sense of Article 2(11) of Directive 1999/93/EC).

Some of the physical or binary (logical) objects generated or issued as a result of the provision of a certification service may be entitled to a specific ‘qualification’ on the basis of their compliance with the provisions and requirements laid down at national level, but the meaning of such a ‘qualification’ is likely to be limited solely to the national level.

One single Trusted List must be established and maintained per Member State to indicate the supervision and/or accreditation status of those certification services from those CSPs that are supervised/accredited by the Member State. The Trusted List shall include at least those CSPs issuing QCs. The Trusted List may also indicate the status of other certification services supervised or accredited under a nationally defined approval scheme.

In the Trusted List, the fact that a service is currently either ‘supervised’ or ‘accredited’ is given by the value of its current status. In addition to that, a supervision or accreditation status can be positive (‘under supervision’, ‘accredited’, ‘supervision in cessation’), ceased (‘supervision ceased’, ‘accreditation ceased’), or even revoked (‘supervision revoked’, ‘accreditation revoked’) and be set to the corresponding value. Throughout its lifetime, the same certification service may move from a supervision status to an accreditation status and vice versa [E.g. a certification service provider established in a Member State that provides a certification service that is initially supervised by the Member State (Supervisory Body), can, after a certain time, decide to pass a voluntary accreditation for the currently supervised certification service. Conversely, a certification service provider in another Member State can decide not to stop an accredited certification service but to move it from an accreditation status to a supervision status, e.g. for business and/or economic reasons.].

Figure 1 below describes the expected flow, for one single certification service, between possible supervision/accreditation statuses:

When established in a Member State, a certification service issuing QCs must be supervised (by the Member State in which it is established) and may be voluntarily accredited. The status value of such a service when listed in a Trusted List must have one of the above depicted status values as ‘current status value’ in accordance with its actual status and must change, when applicable, according to the status flow depicted above. However, ‘Accreditation ceased’ and ‘Accreditation revoked’ must both be ‘transit status’ values when the corresponding CSPQC service is listed in the Trusted List of the Member State in which it is established, as such a service must be supervised by default (even when not or no longer accredited); when the corresponding service is listed (accredited) in another Member State than the one it is established in, these values may be final values.

Member States establishing or having established a nationally defined ‘recognised approval scheme(s)’ implemented on a national basis for the supervision of compliance of services from CSPs not issuing QCs with the provisions laid down in Directive 1999/93/EC and with possible national provisions with regard to the provision of certification services (in the sense of Article 2(11) of Directive 1999/93/EC) must categorise such approval scheme(s) under the following two categories:

‘voluntary accreditation’ as defined and regulated in Directive 1999/93/EC (Article 2(13), Article 3(2), Article 7(1)(a), Article 8(1), Article 11, recitals 4, 11, 12 and 13),

‘supervision’ as required in Directive 1999/93/EC and implemented by national provisions and requirements in accordance with national laws.

Accordingly, a certification service not issuing QCs may be supervised or voluntarily accredited. The status value of such a service when listed in a Trusted List must have one of the above depicted status values as its ‘current status value’ (see Figure 1) in accordance with its actual status and must evolve, when applicable, according to the status flow depicted above.

The Trusted List must contain information about the underlying supervision/accreditation scheme(s), in particular:

Information on the supervision system applicable to any CSPQC,

Information, when applicable, on the national ‘voluntary accreditation’ scheme applicable to any CSPQC,

Information, when applicable, on the supervision system applicable to any CSP not issuing QCs,

Information, when applicable, on the national ‘voluntary accreditation’ scheme applicable to any CSP not issuing QCs.

The last two sets of information are of critical importance for relying parties to assess the quality and security level of such supervision/accreditation systems applied at national level to CSPs not issuing QCs. When supervision/accreditation status information is provided in the Trusted List with regard to services from CSPs not issuing QCs, the aforementioned sets of information shall be provided at Trusted List level through the use of ‘Scheme information URI’ (clause 5.3.7 — information being provided by Member States), ‘Scheme type/community/rules’ (clause 5.3.9 — through the use of a text common to all Member States, and optional specific information provided by a Member State) and ‘TSL policy/legal notice’ (clause 5.3.11 — a text common to all Member States referring to Directive 1999/93/EC, together with the ability for each Member State to add Member State specific text/references).

Additional ‘qualification’ information defined at the level of national supervision/accreditation systems for CSPs not issuing QCs may be provided at the service level when applicable and required (e.g. to distinguish between several quality/security levels) through the use of ‘additionalServiceInformation Extension’ (clause 5.5.9.4) as part of ‘Service information extensions’ (clause 5.5.9). Further information on the corresponding technical specifications is provided in the detailed specifications in Chapter I.

Despite the fact that separate bodies of a Member State may be in charge of the supervision and accreditation of certification services in that Member State, it is expected that only one entry must be used for one single certification service and that its supervision/accreditation status must be updated accordingly.

The most critical part of the creation of the Trusted List is the establishment of the mandatory part of the Trusted List, namely the ‘List of services’ per CSP issuing QCs, in order to reflect correctly the exact situation of each QC-issuing certification service and to ensure that the information provided in each entry is sufficient to facilitate the validation of QES and AdESQC (when combined with the content of the end-entity QC issued by the CSP under the certification service listed in this entry).

The required information might include information other than the ‘Service digital identity’ of a single (Root) CA, in particular information identifying the QC status of certificates issued by such a CA service, and whether or not the supported signatures are created by an SSCD. The Body in a Member State that is designated to establish, edit and maintain the Trusted List must therefore take into account the current profile and certificate content in each issued QC, per CSPQC service covered by the Trusted List.

Ideally each issued QC should include the ETSI defined QcCompliance [Refer to ETSI EN 319 412-5 (Electronic Signatures and Infrastructures (ESI); Profiles for Trust Service Providers issuing certificates; Part 5: Extension for Qualified Certificate profile) for the definition of such a statement.] statement when it is claimed that it is a QC and should include the ETSI defined QcSSCD statement when it is claimed that it is supported by an SSCD to generate eSignatures, and/or that each issued QC includes one of the QCP/QCP+ certificate policy Object Identifiers (OIDs) defined in ETSI EN 319 411-2 [ETSI EN 319 411-2 — Electronic Signatures and Infrastructures (ESI); Policy and security requirements for Trust Service Providers issuing certificates; Part 2: Policy requirements for certification authorities issuing qualified certificates.]. The use by CSPs issuing QCs of different standards as references, the wide degree of interpretation of those standards as well as the lack of awareness of the existence and precedence of some normative technical specifications or standards has resulted in differences in the actual content of currently issued QCs (e.g. the use or not of those QcStatements defined by ETSI) and consequently are preventing the receiving parties from simply relying on the signatory’s certificate (and associated chain/path) to assess, at least in a machine readable way, whether or not the certificate supporting an eSignature is claimed to be a QC and whether or not it is associated with an SSCD through which the eSignature has been created.

Completing the ‘Service type identifier’ (‘Sti’), ‘Service name’ (‘Sn’), and ‘Service digital identity’ (‘Sdi’) fields of the service entry in the Trusted List with information provided in the ‘Service information extensions’ (‘Sie’) field allows for the full determination of a specific type of qualified certificate issued by a listed CSP certification service issuing QCs and provides information about whether or not it is supported by an SSCD (when such information is missing in the issued QC). A specific ‘Service current status’ (‘Scs’) information is associated with this entry. This is depicted in Figure 2 below.

Listing a service by just providing the ‘Sdi’ of a (Root) CA would mean that it is ensured (by the CSP issuing QCs but also by the Supervisory/Accreditation Body in charge of the supervision/accreditation of this CSP) that any end-entity certificate issued under this (Root) CA (hierarchy) contains enough ETSI defined and machine-processable information to assess whether or not it is a QC, and whether or not it is supported by an SSCD. In the event, for example, that the latter assertion is not true (e.g. there is no ETSI standardised machine-processable indication in the QC about whether it is supported by an SSCD), then by listing only the ‘Sdi’ of that (Root) CA, it can only be assumed that QCs issued under this (Root) CA hierarchy are not supported by any SSCD. In order to indicate that those QCs must be considered as supported by an SSCD, the ‘Sie’ field should be used (this also indicates that this information is guaranteed by the CSP issuing QCs and supervised/accredited by the Supervisory or Accreditation Body respectively).

The present Trusted List common template technical specifications allow for the use of a combination of five main parts of information in the service entry:

The ‘Service type identifier’ (‘Sti’), e.g. identifying a CA issuing QCs (‘CA/QC’),

The ‘Service name’ (‘Sn’),

This article is long: the rest is at the official publication.