The Commission rejects those arguments. Firstly, the Commission notes that in a cartel and for the purpose of determining the appropriate fine there can be three categories of cartel members: leaders, active members and passive members. In the present case, AWA was the overall cartel leader. The Commission considers that all the other cartel members, including Carrs and Copigraph (Bolloré), were active members. Carrs and Copigraph participated regularly in the cartel meetings on their national markets. Carrs has even stated that it participated in a larger number of UK and Irish market meetings than identified in the Statement of Objections. Copigraph (Bolloré), which had more sales outside its home market than Carrs, was also a regular participant in the general cartel meetings. There is also large amount evidence on their participation in the price increase initiatives showing that they regularly announced to the customers the agreed or concerted price increases.
Recital 426, Decision_act (EU) 2004/337
In forcesince 20 Dec 2001