The Commission must dismiss AWA's, MHTP's (Stora), Koehler's and Sappi's arguments. Above all, the mere fact that price announcements were made in amount and timing following concertation suffices to show an impact on the market. During the period covered by this Decision the carbonless paper market was declining; there was large structural over-capacity and demand was decreasing. There were short, temporary increases in demand only due to customers' stock-building. Moreover, several parties to the cartel have reported in their replies to the Statement of Objections on large and persistent losses during the period concerned. Some confirm that these losses were a reason for them to join the cartel. Minutes of the official AEMCP meetings even record that, faced with these difficulties, the parties were considering the sending of a crisis cartel exemption application to the Commission. The Commission accepts that in such a market situation the prices can be expected to decrease, but considers that this does not exclude that the cartel managed to control or limit the price decrease. Consequently, the cartel may have impeded the production capacity to adjust naturally to the demand by maintaining inefficient competitors in the market longer than they would have stayed under normal conditions of competition.
Recital 392, Decision_act (EU) 2004/337
In forcesince 20 Dec 2001