Recital 390, Decision_act (EU) 2004/337

In forcesince 20 Dec 2001

AWA has submitted an expert report(359), the main purpose of which is to demonstrate that although concertation did take place during the period from 1992 to mid 1995, it was not effective in raising prices above levels that would have prevailed in the absence of any cartel meetings.

–

The characteristics of the carbonless paper market make successful price fixing very difficult. The report underlines in this respect the lack of sufficient concentration on the supply side, disparity in size of firms, low barriers to entry and high fixed costs.

–

In the period 1994-1997 there is little relationship between the price increases announced and the actual prices obtained. To a large degree realised prices moved in line with the price of pulp.

–

Identical price increases can be explained by economic theory, and do not necessarily signify concerted behaviour.

–

The fluctuations in AWA's market shares in different countries shows that no effective concerted behaviour took place.

–

Excerpts from AWA's business plans for the period 1993-1997, each of which provide commentary on market outcomes in the previous year, indicate that competition between carbonless producers continued to be vigorous with customers being won and lost.