Recital 300, Decision_act (EU) 2004/337

In forcesince 20 Dec 2001

The Spanish companies, Torraspapel, Zicuñaga and Divipa contest in totality the findings made by the Commission in the Statement of Objections. These companies pretend that the Commission has failed to provide direct evidence of any collusion and/or participation of them to these arrangements and misinterpreted the existing documents. In addition, they argue that the statements made by Sappi, Mougeot and AWA can not be held as valid proofs of an infringement and that the statements are even suspect since those are not vouching their authenticity. According to the Spanish companies, the Commission has merely accepted the statements of Sappi, AWA and Mougeot without checking them and carrying out the necessary investigations. Zicuñaga also claims that the documents given by Sappi do not constitute a proof of the cartel because Sappi was not vouching for their authenticity. Furthermore, the Spanish companies claim that Sappi, AWA and Mougeot have an interest in concentrating the Commission's attention on the markets of Spain and Portugal, which are minor compared to those where Sappi, AWA and Mougeot have more important activities (like UK and France)(329).