However, an argument against ranking this as a very serious infringement is the fact that the weighted method applied in this decision to determine the margin squeeze has not previously been the subject of a formal Commission decision. This having been said, the margin squeeze test as such forms part of the well-established decision making practice of the Commission, and the new element is the weighted approach which had to be used in this case to take into account the fact that in Germany, a single wholesale tariff for local loop unbundling has been fixed, while the tariffs for the corresponding retail services differentiate between analogue, ISDN and ADSL lines. A second argument for ranking the infringement as serious and not very serious is that through tariff adjustments at retail and wholesale level, DT has steadily reduced the margin squeeze, since 1999 at least. Lastly, for the period since 1 January 2002, DT's only legal means of reducing the margin squeeze has been limited to increases in the T-DSL charges.
Recital 206, Decision_act (EU) 2003/707
In forcesince 21 May 2003