The Commission must however reject these arguments. Whereas the participants (including Rhône-Poulenc) have submitted evidence in support of their claim that Sumitomo broke off the cooperation at the end of 1988, no evidence was submitted in support of the claim that the remaining parties to the cartel would have announced to each other any intention to terminate the arrangement or end the contacts. On the contrary, the Commission has evidence that the operations of the cartel went on throughout 1989 and 1990:
Nippon Soda makes it clear that there was no such break in continuity: if the high-level annual "summit" meetings had indeed ended, the regular staff-level meetings continued uninterrupted through 1989 and 1990(16),
in August 1989 a meeting took place between Nippon Soda, Degussa and Rhône-Poulenc (see recitals 98 and 99),
in or around May 1990 the cartel members contacted each other on the issue of raising the methionine prices as from July 1990 (see recitals 100 to 106),
Rhône-Poulenc admits meeting Degussa on 10 June 1990 to discuss falling prices (see recitals 107 and 108),
in November 1990 the participants met again and agreed to increase their prices (see recitals 112 and 115 to 120).