Recital 125, Decision_act (EU) 2003/674

In forcesince 2 Jul 2002

It admits to just two earlier meetings (it says they were in 1991) with Rhône-Poulenc (in Paris and Frankfurt) but claims that they were unconnected with the "summit" meetings; the two producers (it says) conducted a general exchange on market development and production capacities in methionine. These meetings may actually have been the three identified by Rhône-Poulenc as taking place in Frankfurt in June and August 1990 and in Paris in late 1990 before the Far East meeting with Nippon Soda. It is also clear from Rhône-Poulenc's account that they were not of the relatively innocent nature claimed by Degussa. In its reply to the Commission's statement of objections, Degussa states that it simply has no recollection of meetings organised prior to the two meetings in 1991, given that no current employees of Degussa have any recollection of the arrangements prior to 1992. It also submits that the Commission has no exact dates for meetings in 1990 or 1991. However, in the light of the evidence contained in the preceding paragraphs, the Commission can dismiss this argument.