Recital 94, Decision_act (EU) 2003/515

In forcesince 17 Feb 2003

The Commission cannot endorse the argument that the sole purpose of the minimum four countries/two continents requirement is to provide objective criteria which can be used to assess whether the basic requirements are met. Although it is logical to set certain limits or thresholds in a tax structure to ensure that it works properly, this should not result in excessive demands being made which are not proportionate to the desired aims. Objectively speaking, groups which are active in only three countries or on one continent are no less exposed to the risks associated with international financing activities. On the other hand, there seems to be no doubt that the number of companies which do not meet the gfa scheme's criteria far exceeds the number of those which do. In that sense, and in the light of the Court of First Instance's recent Alava judgment(27), it has not been proven that the measure is justified by the nature or aims of the Dutch tax system. Thus measures to combat erosion of the tax base or improve the lack of competitiveness which group financing activities in the Netherlands suffered from before 1997 do not justify the award of State aid to a limited number of companies. This principle was established in the Court of Justice judgment in Case 173/73(28).

  • Judgment of the Court of 2 July 1974. Italian Republic v Commission of the European Communities.Decision

    2 Jul 1974 · 61973CJ0173