Recital 84, Decision_act (EU) 2003/515

In forcesince 17 Feb 2003

Second, the advantage must be granted through State resources. In this case, the Commission takes the view that the measure is granted through State resources because the tax reduction awarded, irrespective of whether it takes the form of exemption or a lower rate, leads to a reduction in State revenue. As the Netherlands has stated in its capacity as an interested party, the measure has not given rise to a loss of revenue for the State but, on the contrary, has prevented companies leaving the Netherlands and has helped to entice them back or to set up there, which compensated for the loss of revenue resulting from the reduction in the tax burden. The Commission cannot share this assessment, which is based on a cost-benefit analysis. The fact that a reduction in revenue can be compensated for subsequently by an increase in the number of taxpayers as a result of the measure does not mean that the measure is not financed from State resources. Whether a measure constitutes aid must be assessed at a given time at the level of individual companies with a view to determining whether some companies receive more State aid or contribute less to financing public goods and services. Otherwise any type of aid would be justified in so far as it enticed a company to set up in a given Member State, enabled it to increase its future taxable revenue or prevented it from leaving the country.

7.3. Negative impact on competition and trade between Member States