Recital 102, Decision_act (EU) 2003/515

In forcesince 17 Feb 2003

Lastly, the gfa scheme cannot be considered to be existing aid within the meaning of Article 1(b)(v) of the procedural regulation because all the elements of State aid were present from the time when the measure was introduced. Nor had it been demonstrated that the common market has evolved. Because even if the third phase of economic and monetary union had already been launched, and increasing globalisation was already a reality, these notable events nevertheless formed part of ongoing processes which had started long before the gfa scheme was approved. The third phase of monetary union is the culmination of attempts to coordinate exchange-rate policy which began in the 1970s. For its part, globalisation can be traced back to the multilateral nature of the GATT Agreement(30) immediately after the war. As far as the aforementioned Commission notice is concerned, as the Court of First Instance observed in the Alava judgment(31), it is substantially based on the case-law of the Court of Justice and the Court of First Instance and merely elucidates the application to tax measures of Articles 87 and 88 of the Treaty. Even assuming that the Commission's decision-making practice has changed, as underlined by the Court of First Instance in its Gibraltar judgment(32), the answer to whether a measure constitutes existing aid or new aid cannot depend on a subjective assessment by the Commission but must be answered independently of its previous administrative practice.

7.6. Investigation into compatibility