Recital 113, Decision_act (EU) 2002/742

In forcesince 5 Dec 2001

There is some discrepancy in the accounts given by the various participants as to the actual date on which Cerestar Bioproducts attended its first cartel meeting. Hoffmann-La Roche has stated that "representatives of Cerestar did not attend meetings before the year 1992"(52). ADM believes that Cerestar Bioproducts only joined the cartel at its meeting of 18 November 1992 in Brussels(53), whilst Jungbunzlauer puts it at 1 June 1993(54), although Jungbunzlauer admits that it is unsure of this. Cerestar Bioproducts, for its part, is adamant that it was present at the meeting in Jerusalem in May 1992(55) and it is this date which must be accepted as being the most accurate, mainly because Cerestar Bioproducts was the smallest player in the cartel and its participation at meetings was not systematically recorded by the other participants.