Recital 101, Decision_act (EU) 2002/742

In forcesince 5 Dec 2001

The tables provided by Jungbunzlauer(39) were drawn up on the basis of the data supplied through those monthly telephone calls and contain detailed figures and calculations of the monthly sales of each participant in the cartel. They show a constant monitoring of each individual undertaking's level of compliance with its sales quota. As to the interpretation of the tables themselves, Jungbunzlauer explains: "The five rows 1 to 5 arranged one below the other show Haarmann & Reimer, ADM, Jungbunzlauer, Hoffmann-La Roche and Cerestar (respectively). The twelve columns arranged side by side show these firms" reported monthly sales volumes. For each firm there are four separate rows showing the volume of citric acid sold in Europe, North America, and the rest of the world, and the total for the three regions together. The row marked "total" also shows the percentage difference from the agreed sales volumes. The last row shows the difference for Europe as a whole(40). Two separate tables exist for each year in the period 1991-94. One provides the information on a cumulative monthly basis and the other on a simple monthly basis.

(c)

Compensation system