Recital 184, Decision_act (EU) 1996/435

In forcesince 16 Jan 1996

The combined entity, KC/S, would therefore enjoy a dominant position in the UK and Ireland in consumer markets for toilet-tissue and facial tissues/handkerchiefs, which would not be capable of effective challenge by existing competitors.

With regard to kitchen towels, the Commission recognizes that the percentage of the market covered by private-label products is higher than for toilet-tissue and facial tissues/handkerchiefs and that the market position of KC/S in relation to the sale of branded kitchen towels is not as strong as that for toilet-tissue and facial tissues/handkerchiefs. Nevertheless, the Commission considers the combined entity would quickly acquire a dominant position for kitchen towels incapable of adequate control by competitors. Immediately after the merger KC/S would become the clear market leader for branded products. While its market share for branded products would be only 19,8 %, it would supply over half the market's current branded product requirements and would have a branded products market share four times larger than its next competitor and eight times greater than the next again. Including its share of private-label sales, KC/S would have a production share in the market of [40-50 %] (55). It would hold the two strongest brands and possess the only TAD plant in the UK, the TAD production technology being particularly suitable for the production of high-quality kitchen towels. By building on its strength across the range of consumer tissue products and engaging in a vigorous marketing and publicity campaign, the Commission considers that it would be in a position to acquire, relatively quickly, a dominant position for kitchen towels. Indeed, as is evident from the data quoted in Table 5 in the Annex, advertising expenditure has been limited for kitchen towels and as remarked by retailers, before the merger there is no strong brand leader and brand investment has been relatively small. This position would of course change after the merger. In this light the Commission considers that the parties will hold a dominant position for kitchen towels.

Retailer buyer bargaining power