Therefore, based on the studies submitted it cannot be excluded that private labels compete with branded products. Indeed it is quite normal to have a certain degree of competition between various product categories even in differentiated product markets. From a common sense perspective this would also seem reasonable for the British toilet-tissue market given that some private labels are positioned as high quality brands. However, the overall characteristics of the British toilet-tissue market means that it simply cannot be accepted that this should be a commodity market where brands are of little importance. Firstly, branded products account for almost half of the market, and Andrex, the most important brand, has almost [30-40 %] (53) of the market. Secondly, the two leading brands command a high price premium. This is in itself an indication of the presence of brand loyalty and brand equity. Thirdly, the two leading brands are 'must carry goods` and serve as reference points for the whole market. Therefore, considering all the facts it would rather seem that possession of the two leading brands in combination with the position as a leading supplier of super soft private labels would give Kimberly Clark/Scott Paper considerable leverage on the whole market of branded as well as private-label toilet-tissue. In this case the inelastic price elasticities for total toilet-tissue demand estimated by both Cambridge Economics and Lexecon ([. . .] respectively (54)) certainly mean that there would be scope for the parties to abuse their position on the whole British market for toilet-tissue following the merger.
Competitive pressure exerted by independent converters