London Economics in their study prepared for the parties gives the impression of the UK toilet-tissue market being a commodity type of market, where brands and advertising are not important factors. The study argues that toilet-tissue is a short-term experience good with low switching costs where the quality of the product is known immediately after use. According to London Economics such products normally exhibit low brand loyalty. Particularly, the study concludes that private labels constrain the pricing of branded products because:
'manufacturer brands and own brands are regarded by many consumers as substitutes;
switching costs are very low in the toilet-tissue market
and
competition takes places mainly in terms of price. Advertising is often used to support this form of competition,
advertising does not represent a significant barrier to entry into this market. This is especially true for a potential branded supplier such as Procter & Gamble or SCA/PWA
and
due to the vigorous nature of competition between UK retailers, shelf space is not a significant barrier to entry. This is because consumers attach value to the choice as well as to price and quality, of products that the retailer stocks. Retailers will always do better by stocking a wider range of successful products.` (London Economics, pp. 26 and following).