Recital 136, Decision_act (EU) 1996/435

In forcesince 16 Jan 1996

The Commission also requested the multiples to comment on brand loyalty. The replies were as follows:

Retailer A

'The brands spend considerable sums of money in marketing their products while private label uses mainly its store image to promote the product.

There are loyal customers to both brand and private label. On the other hand, there are customers who are prompted by promotional activity who will switch from one to another.`

Retailer B

'consumers, in our view, do show loyalty to branded products especially in toilet-tissue, due to the historically known softness of the product.`

Retailer C

'There is strong brand loyalty in the toilet-tissue market and in the facial tissue market, with Andrex dominating branded toilet-tissue sales and Kleenex dominating branded facial tissues.

In the kitchen towel market, own label dominates but this is partly to do with the fact that there is not one strong brand in the market, but several secondary brands which when put together, add up to a significant percentage of total market sales.`

Retailer D

'Consumers do show loyalty to branded tissue products primarily due to the heavy weight of marketing spend.`

Retailer E

'Brand loyalty varies by sector and can be influenced by promotional and advertising activity.

Toilet-tissue: significant brand loyalty due to the dominance of the leading Andrex and Kimberly-Clark brands . . ., which are both long-standing and heavily supported brands. However, despite continuing heavy promotional activity, own brand continues to increase steadily.

Kitchen towels: dominated by private label and secondary/tertiary brands, with no dominant brand leaders. Brand investment in this sector has been relatively small.

Facial tissues: Kleenex, as the brand leader, commands strong loyalty, particularly in man-size tissues.`