European Monetary Cooperation Fund (EMCF) was established by Council Regulation (EEC) No 907/73 of 3 April 1973 (OJ No L 89, 5.4.1973).
Chapter 4 analyzes the decision making procedures in force for the loans at the Commission and between the Commission and the EIB.
Chapter 5 examines the financial management procedures for the mechanisms.
Chapter 6 reviews the manner in which the external audit of the mechanisms has been defined.
Summary of the observations
Decision-making procedures
1.7. Euratom loans (a) The Commission's EIB Inter-Service Group deliberations on projects are difficult to analyze in the absence of substantive minutes of their meetings.
(para. 4.37)
The criteria which the EIB uses in its evaluation of a project are not explicit in the Cooperation Agreement between the Commission and its agent, the EIB.
(para. 4.37)
1.8. NCI loans (a) The Commission in its role of deciding on the eligibility of projects, has not interpreted explicitly the Council's general eligibility guidelines for NCI loans.
(para. 4.38)
As with Euratom loans, the Commission's EIB Inter-Service Group does not hold minutes of its deliberations on projects submitted for NCI loans.
(para. 4.39)
Loans granted under the NCI mechanism appear equivalent to EIB loans except that the former are financed by Commission borrowings.
(para. 4.40)
There is no consistency between the allocation of responsibilities decided for the NCI mechanism in 1978 when compared to those decided for the Euratom mechanism in 1977.
(para. 4.41)
The Court considers that it would be preferable if, in the interests of consistency between mechanisms and due to the Community's direct financial responsibility for its borrowings, the Commission was granted responsibility for making the NCI loan decisions.
(para. 4.41.)
1.9. EMS interest rate subsidies (a) The Cooperation Agreement adopted by the Commission and the EIB on the practical implementation of the EMS interest subsidies requires a number of important clarifications with regard to the decision-making process.
(para. 4.44)
The Cooperation Agreement does not define the criteria used in the initial selection of projects for consideration for interest subsidies.
(para. 4.44 (i))
The Cooperation Agreement does not define the criteria used in allocating the annual budgetary appropriations (200 million EUA) for the EMS subsidies between NCI and EIB loans.
(para. 4.44 (ii))
The Cooperation Agreement does not define the Commission's interpretations of the Council's eligibility guidelines for interest rate subsidies.
(para. 4.44 (iii))
It is the EIB decision to grant the NCI loan and/or EIB loan to a project which determines if that project shall receive an EMS interest subsidy financed by the Community budget.
(para. 4.45)
This decision-making process appears contrary to Article 205 of the EEC Treaty wherein the Commission is charged with the implementation of the budget.
(para. 4.45)
Financial management
1.10. BP mechanism (a) Contracts to be concluded by the Commission are not submitted for the approval of the Commission's financial controller prior to signature.
(para. 5.24)
The Commission's accounting officer should (i) ascertain the EMCF's method of verifying the BIS's (Bank of International Settlements) accounts.
Confirm with the lending banks and/or central banks of the beneficiary Member States the outstanding balances at the yearend for the loans and borrowings.
(para. 5.23)
1.11. Euratom and NCI mechanisms (a) There is no consistency between the Euratom and NCI mechanisms with regard to the arrangements for the financial management of the mechanisms.
(paras 5.9 to 5.11)
DG XVIII administers the financial transactions associated with the above mechanisms independently of both the Commission's financial controller and accounting officer.
(para. 5.27)
DG XVIII has its own accounting system independently of the Commission's accounting officer.
(para. 5.26)
There is no involvement of the Commission's financial controller at the contract stage nor is his approval sought for the individual financial transactions relating to the loans and borrowings.
(paras 5.13 to 5.14 and 5.25)
The concentration of functions at DG XVIII is in contradiction with a basic principle of internal control and with the Commission's own proposals on the "budgetization" of loans and borrowings.
(paras 5.28 to 5.31)
1.12. EMS interest rate subsidies (a) The volume of budgetary appropriations ultimately utilized is dependent on the EIB's loan decision(s) rather than the Commission's eligibility decision.
(paras 5.16 and 5.32)
The Commission does not possess original supporting documents for the payment of interest subsidies on EIB loans.
(paras 5.17 and 5.33)
The Cooperation Agreement on EMS interest subsidies between the Commission and the EIB does not indicate how 75 % of the annual rate of interest was decided for the calculation of the present value of the interest subsidies.
(paras 5.18 and 5.34)
There have been differences in the disposal of the interest rate subsidies by the EIB between Italian and Irish projects.
(paras 5.19 and 5.35)
External audit of the mechanisms
1.13. BP mechanism (a) The EMCF's directive to the BIS, its agent, should contain a clause pertaining to the Court's right of audit of the administration of the BP loans and borrowings.
(paras 6.2 to 6.6)
1.14. NCI mechanisms and EMS interest subsidies: (a) The bilateral Cooperation Agreements between the Commission and the EIB incorporated additional audit clauses which are contradictory to the audit provisions of Article 206 of the EEC Treaty and these clauses should be deleted.
(paras 6.4 to 6.7)
General
1.15. The introduction of these mechanisms may not be construed as the result of a Council decision of the financing of Community policies. Consequently, the attributions of responsibilities for the granting and administration of the loans differ from one mechanism to another.
(para. 7.1)
1.16. The Court of Auditors considers that it would be preferable if the Commission introduced internal procedures for the decision making and financial management of the loans and borrowings analogous to those procedures contained in the Financial Regulation.
(para. 7.6)
1.17. As a general policy, cooperation agreements/contracts agreed with third parties by the Commission or other Community institutions should automatically incorporate an audit provision stating clearly that the Treaties audit provisions are applicable.
(para. 7.5)